"Construction" as evidence of presence for molluscs

Trash piles are ‘evidence of eating’ but not a construction.
A bagworm uses ‘trash’ as a construction to live in.
Anthill is evidence of the construction below.

As I understand it, the octopus doesn’t just drop the remains of its prey at random. The midden is positioned so as to conceal the entrance to its hideout, and it adds non-prey items to the pile, as well - small rocks, shells, chunks of coral, etc.

I would most definitely argue the case that a shell annotation is useful.
My rationale is that, currently, the way of indicating that just a mollusc’s shell is present is by annotating as dead. This doesn’t distinguish observations immediately from those where the animal is dead, too. The workaround is to filter by dead and presence of organism. But that doesn’t guarantee that observations which are dead and are not annotated for evidence of presence to be just of shells.

A particularly relevant use case is the recent South Australian harmful algal bloom, where users are uploading tens of thousands of dead molluscs to a dedicated project. To be included, observations have to be marked as dead. But, for molluscs, the most relevant observations are those where the animal is depicted as dead, too. I think it would be highly useful to quickly distinguish just shells (lower evidence of HAB effects, and may include old shells pre-HAB) from dead animals (better evidence of HAB effects).
Yes, I could just annotate observations so that shells are only marked as dead, and animals marked as dead and having an organism present. But I do think if such a trivial workaround has to be made, we might as well have a shell annotation—especially when people are trying to use another annotation entirely. Better yet, maybe a more appropriate new annotation would be “Shell only”.

This is another point that I was going to bring up. I can think of very few cases of “construction” applying to molluscs, even fewer still that aren’t covered by other annotations (like egg casings, which can also be constructions).

Even moving past just the incorrect use of “construction”, I think that an annotation option that is either “shell” or something along the lines of “soft parts/body” would be beyond nice just for the filtering ability when looking for photos of certain structures. For molluscs such as the river mussels I work with, the vast majority of observations are only an empty shell, whether it’s living or dead, and it’s not always intuitive to everyone to mark this as “organism”. But some observations have soft parts, and rarely, a photo of the crazy mantle lure structures. But there’s not really a way to reliably filter for observations showing this, unless I search via the tags filter or sort by faves, and hope that a key word or high number of faves gets me there. Since the tags feature is almost never used, an annotation to denote soft parts and shell would be so much more useful for finding photos of specific structures IMO

I got shot down on the modifications needed to properly support invertebrate annotations. Echo chamber here.

so unfortunate… if bird can have feather… why can’t snail have shell :melting_face: lol

It’s true for any arthropod. Take crayfish. Often you’ll be moseying along a river and see a carapace or claw. Evidence of presence = shell, not the entire organism, or a shed. There are undoubtely dozens of permutations which are far too numerous to manage to please everyone. Perhaps it’s just getting too much in the weeds, and all annotations need to be made personal or project based and left to the user to decide what they find important.

Maybe we could find out by filtering for mollusc constructions, if only the annotation was used correctly?

Why do we have to justify the existence of mollusk constructions to address the issue that the mollusk construction annotation is systemically missused per iNaturalist definitions? Even if no mollusk constructions exist, ok. Why are there over 10k annotations of something that doesnt exist?

I think this is clearly an issue and is nearly unfixable without staff intervention / change to annotations. You cant even change annotations, only downvote them. Likely 1000s will stay stuck for ever.

Because if they don’t exist, there would be a strong argument for removing the annotation “construction” from all mollusc taxa. Or it would not matter because people could simply ignore this annotation as meaningless.

But if there are potential legitimate uses of “construction” for mollusc observations, the question of what to do about the misuse of the annotation becomes more difficult to solve.

This.

I agree. I see a lot of value in having an annotation option for specifying “shell only.”

This is what I had put into my feature request, but then discovered the staff were not taking more suggestions. But I’m a maverick, so here is my blurb:

Gastropods leave the following evidence: “Organism, Shell, Egg, Seal, Epiphragm, Slime, Scat, Trail”. I’ve included biological detail. Construction may be too broad, there are biological reasons, below.

  1. Shell needs to be added; it is a permanent feature of the organism, you’ll see why I specify permanent in a moment. (This should be an option for all invertebrates, but I don’t see it listed?) Many slugs also have a portion of visible shell, but some retain a remnant within the mantle used for muscle attachment. It is only very infrequently observed, because people aren’t looking for it. Some snails also have an operculum, essentially a trap door to plug the aperture.
  2. Snails may seal their aperture directly to the surface, aka the apertural seal. This is a calcareous glue slime that dries like cement. It anchors the edge of the apertural lip to the surface, making it very difficult to detach the snail. This is done for defense, aestivation which mitigates moisture loss and inadvertent detachment during hostile weather. In some taxa, this leaves a near-permanent mark on habitat. If you investigate within their refugia, you may find stones covered in hundreds of hard, calcareous seals.
  3. Snails produce an apertural membrane, or epiphragm. This is a slime plug that serves to reduce moisture loss and for defense. They produce this when entering aestivation or if resting in a sketchy place. Snails suffering from prolonged dehydration may make several of these as they shrink further back into the shell (they may be doomed, unfortunately when this happens too many times). When they emerge, the membrane plug is pushed out the aperture, and is sometimes left behind. Normally it is consumed as it emerges from the shell.
  4. Some taxa wrap themselves in a slime “cocoon”, or mate while dangling on a slime cord.
  5. Snails and slugs leave slime trails. You can see these even during dry condition because of the reflective nanocrystals. This may not be the “track” as is intended.

And add to that, Nest, which is a construction.

Some species have a hard, calcareous operculum (e.g., Turbinidae), and these are often found separate from the shell itself.

I was trying to avoid being too much in the weeds. Shell as a term to mean some manner of calcareous structure, such as the shell itself and operculum. Shell is to invertebrate as bone is to vertebrate, or in the case of turtles, a shell too. Aaaaaaahhhhhhh it never ends, does it? … or there’s the beak, or the cuttle-bone it just never ends if we get into the nitty-gritty. Shell. That is good enough.

I feel like you’ve made a pretty good case and the community seems on board, but I don’t know what the best avenue is for getting staff/developer feedback since staff input on specific subjects has declined across the board in the past couple years.

It all comes down to money and priorities. Balancing popular use with ridiculously persnickety scientitifical people is a pain, and hope they are managing to not tear their last hair follicles out. We all want the same thing.

The banner at the top has a table with issues for each proposal that apparently need to be addressed:

Are there any taxa outside of Mollusca that would be relevant? The Seashells of the World project also includes sand dollars and stony corals.

To respond to this specifically, for bivalves at least I believe it’s often valuable to see the hinge area on dead and empty shells. In this case it’s useful to be able to search for observations where the organism is both dead and no flesh is left.

And personally, this is what “shell” intuitively means to me - when it’s alive or a dead body it’s a whole animal, not a shell. There are many cases where you can see horns/antlers/teeth on live mammals but I wouldn’t annotate those as “evidence of presence: bone”.

Unless you are a diver, shells on the beach, dead, and empty of flesh, are how you see marine molluscs. (Or live in the intertidal zone) Being able to choose ‘photos of shells’ is useful to non-divers.

There must be very few observations of shelled mollusks, dead or alive, which do not show the shell. Except in culinary situations, when do we observe one without its shell? Rather than noting the presence of the shell - because that is pretty much a given, I think it would be more useful to note that the soft parts are (at least partially) visible.