Formae specialis of varieties of Puccinia coronata - how to add forms of a variety?

The taxonomy of Puccinia coronata includes formae specialis of varieties, e.g. Puccinia coronata var. avenae f. sp. graminicola. However, these cannot currently be added as the form rank is not considered finer than the variety rank. I am wondering how to add these, as they are genetically distinct (Liu and Hambleton, 2013). In particular P. c. a. graminicola has quite a few records attributable to it on Holcus.

Liu, M., Hambleton, S. Laying the foundation for a taxonomic review of Puccinia coronata s.l. in a phylogenetic context. Mycol Progress 12, 63–89 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11557-012-0814-1

You should raise a flag on the species page here …

https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/1462846-Puccinia-coronata

The forum isn’t intended for taxonomic discussion. That will happen in response to a flag within iNat itself.

I agree with @cooperj that this specific question needs to be addressed by flagging the parent taxon for curation on iNaturalist.

That said, I think the more general question of what to do with formae speciales in Fungi might merit further discussion here, so I’ll start it off.

First, the taxonomic rank forma is different from the informal category forma specialis (see the Code Art. 4 Note 4). The latter is not a rank, and names in that category have no status under the Code of Nomenclature for Algae, Fungi, and Plants.

That said, even if we were talking about a named forma, iNaturalist mirrors the Code in considering all infraspecific ranks to be at a single hierarchic level. Every published subspecies, variety, forma, even subforma, is considered to be a trinomial attached directly to its parent species. Hierarchies among these ranks that authors use to create quadrinomials (or longer) are considered classifications only, not different taxonomic names or combinations. So this is why a forma can only have a species as its parent, not a variety or other infraspecific name.

All that said, I know that iNaturalist gives special leeway to curators of Fungi to add informal or provisional names to its taxonomic backbone for Fungi. It is possible that there is already an accepted practice for incorporating formae speciales of which I am unaware. Any Curators of Fungi please chime in!

already discussed on the subsequent flag

https://www.inaturalist.org/flags/852892

Ah, thanks. The flag must have opened and closed again between the times I checked for one!

@jakedalzell do you think it would still be worth continuing a more general discussion here on how formae speciales are (or could/should be) accommodated in iNaturalist taxonomy?

If not, I’ll close this topic.

Where a host specific form turns out to be monophyletic the trend now is to introduce names at the rank species, or sometimes forma. In general, modern studies show that biological races historically given the status of formae specialis are not monophyletic. The question concerns a paper where they identified monophyletic taxa but did not give them new code compliant names.That is unfortunate. I think the question can be closed.