Is there a preferred way of identifying when when the observer chose “plant” as the ID but the plant has a yellow rust fungus on it and the observer has either left iNaturalist or is unresponsive. Is this an exception to the general rule that we honor the observer’s choice of the subject of the obse…

if the observer added a plant ID, then ID the plant that the rust is growing on or leave the observation alone.

I think it depends on the context of the observation. Sometimes people chose the wrong kingdom because they don’t know what they are looking at, and just assume that because it was growing on a plant, it must be part of the plant. If you’re uncertain, check to see if the observer already has a dupli…

The usual way I see this play out, I don’t change my ID of the plant and in a very short time enough people ID the fungi to make it research grade, so getting stuck at “Life” doesn’t seem to be a problem.

Kingdom Disagreement 21K Not a problem ? Random example from that link I was IDing the spider not the plant Needs 2 more to achieve RG

I see the topic was “unsolved”, so I’ll chime in - it’s pretty solidified identification etiquette to honor the observer’s intention: [image] Identification Etiquette on iNaturalist - Wiki 11. Honour the observer’s intention. If the observation shows a photo of an elephant with its toe touching …

It’s fairly likely that the observer didn’t even notice the rust. In the case of active observers they might like to know about it since they’re curious and want to duplicate the observation for the rust, so it’s worth commenting that the rust is there while still IDing the plant.

If the observer left no other clue than an ID of “Plants”, ID the plant (and maybe leave a comment asking if they’d mind duplicating it for the rust) I’ll only re-ID them when something in the description contradicts their ID (example: Plant with rust, Description reading “Weird orange stuff!” and …

This question reminds me of the classic “Ignore the elephant seal”. https://www.reddit.com/r/whatsthisplant/comments/ki68gp/what_are_these_beach_flowers_ignore_the_elephant/

Just to clarify, there are a lot of observations that look something like this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puccinia_monoica#:\~:text=The%20P.,entire%20life%20cycle%20on%20Arabis . The plant is usually in the mustard family, but the rust distorts the plant. The observer may think that this is a ye…

Tangentially related, is there any way to get CV to ID a plant when it is covered in a rust or mildew? I’ve tried getting IDs for plants before and had nothing come up but a bunch of those, with zero indication of what plant it might be.

Preferred way of dealing with Plant versus Rust Fungi

General

ddennism September 4, 2025, 3:21am 15

Yes, sometimes you can force it to suggest plant IDs if you give it a high level plant ID first (like “Tracheophyta”)

Topic		Replies	Views
What to do when you know an ID is wrong but you don't know what the correct ID is? General question	13	1258	April 15, 2024
Providing an ID on a plant where it's not the most prominent one in the photo General identification	6	470	May 31, 2026
How to fill in the taxon when it is an unknown pathogen General	13	671	October 21, 2021
Any theories as to why so many description section subjects don't match observer's actual ID? General	15	1162	March 3, 2020
How To Go About IDing Unknown IDs General question	7	443	November 18, 2024

Preferred way of dealing with Plant versus Rust Fungi

Related topics