(I searched for a similar topic but didn’t find anything-- if this is discussed elsewhere, please direct me that way) I’ve often found myself starting (and ending) IDs/identification summaries assuming that the observer identified the organism and didn’t simply agree with the “Suggested Identificat…

This little magic tab icon indicates someone selected a computer vision suggestion. [image] (As you say, it’s not possible to tell whether they selected it because they’re just following the suggestion, or if they’re using it as an autofill to save typing time.)

I never understood why the computer vision icon did not got a red colour in stead of a grey one. I use it as an autofill to save time as iPhone app does not keep the original value and always wipes the existing tex away…cause a lot of delay and faults and keeps me typing and typing over and over aga…

[image] serpophaga: I use the suggested IDs often for ‘easy’ stuff that I know and that I know that it knows as it saves typing time). I do this all the time as well, so I would not assume that just because of the “computer vision” icon, someone is just guessing…

As someone who uses the app suggestions a lot for things I know nothing about, I often put a question mark, or two if I’m really doubtful, in the description box just to indicate I really don’t know. I don’t know if this actually helps anyone though.

[image] jenniferlchandler: I often put a question mark, or two if I’m really doubtful, in the description box just to indicate I really don’t know. I think that’s a good idea.

I make a lot of corrections (because mollusk IDs from the AI are very often wrong,) and I for one have never had anyone comment negatively when I correct an ID. Usually they seem to be grateful, whether they got the ID from the AI, or from a book, or from some other kind of guesswork. I do sometime…

I approach this with the attitude that most people are on iNat to learn more about organisms, not prove how much they already know. So, as long as we are friendly and respectful in sharing our knowledge, they almost always seem happy to get the help.

Absolutely! If there’s a problem here, I think the solution is to encourage people to give and receive corrections graciously, not to refrain from offering corrections. We’re all here to teach and to learn. Whether or not the computer vision feature was used is not really relevant, as it’s often us…

[image] bouteloua: it’s not possible to tell whether they selected it because they’re just following the suggestion, or if they’re using it as an autofill to save typing time.) i was thinking about this, along with https://forum.inaturalist.org/t/toggle-computer-vision-suggestions-on-off-on-w…

Signifying User IDs versus Computer IDs

General

serpophaga April 18, 2019, 6:48pm 3

Gahh! I never even noticed that thing!

I clearly have no idea what I’m doing.

Topic		Replies	Views
Computer suggestion should be distinguished from manually entered IDs General question	21	518	March 27, 2024
Problems with Computer Vision and new/inexperienced users General	134	5544	December 27, 2021
Assuming it is right, why wouldn't I use the AI suggestion? General	29	1436	September 5, 2023
Does the computer vision suggest different IDs depending on the user? General	18	707	September 23, 2023
Don't use computer vision General	169	9773	September 18, 2020

Signifying User IDs versus Computer IDs

Related topics