Thanks for the link, I knew a few pages my images were on. But I see there is 50 on the site, and 6 pages using them. I see one there I didnt know. But I do occasionally google myself to see where images are ending up, since I enjoy seeing if they get to help promote different species.
3 Likes
@lythronax246 Nobody can use your images as they are uploaded under the CC BY-NC license. If you wish for your images to be used you can change it to either the CC-BY or CC-BY-SA licenses.
5 Likes
Nice! At least I am contributing with my pictures without knowing after not really upping my game on creating more articles on wikipedia this year 
… 79 of my pictures are there + some I uploaded on my own (and different nickname) when creating some articles
4 Likes
Oh! Interesting. How might I go about doing that?
How might I go about doing that?
Go to “Account Settings”, and then “Content and Display” (top left).
Scroll down to “Licensing”, and select your new default image license.
Check the little box below to apply it to all your previous observation images and hit “Save settings”.
Here is a short (1:44) video made by @andrawaag (and narrated by @siobhanleachman) that demonstrates it nicely.
3 Likes
Hello,
What is the process for asking permission to use images for other purposes e.g., educational material?
Thanks
AH
There isn’t any process; one does not need to ask for permission. One merely needs to comply with the terms of the license.
cf: https://creativecommons.org/about/cclicenses/
CC0 = Public Domain. Do whatever you like with it.
CC BY = Only attribution is required. You may create derivative works. As long as you attribute the creator of the work, you have complied with the license.
CC BY-SA = You must attribute the work to the author AND any derivative work must be licensed under identical terms in order to comply with the license.
Edit: I should add that it doesn’t hurt to tell people that you have used their Creative Commons licensed photos, as most folks do appreciate knowing that they’ve helped someone else, especially an educator or researcher.
10 Likes
For people that also want to share their photo’s with Wikimedia here is a video that explains where to change the license: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zFnJJDTYbJs
2 Likes
I am not a lawyer, but note that the requirements are actually a bit more than just attributing the creator even for CC-BY, you need to do things like repeat any copyright notices, give a source URI, a reference to the license, indicate if changes were made and a few other things (some of these only “to the extent reasonably practicable”).
Most of the time failing to do these extra things probably won’t come back to haunt you since people who are CC-BY licensors usually want their stuff to be reused widely and the most recent license versions include a repair period where your permission (which terminates on breach) gets reinstated if you correct things within 30 days of being made aware of problems. However there are people (so-called “copyleft trolls”) who bank on people not understanding this, who make a lot of CC-licensed stock photography (often under older license versions without repair provisions and/or more exacting technical requirements) then send out manipulatively worded legal threats in bulk alleging technical defects in the attribution strings and demanding settlement money from reusers. This sort of bad-faith predatory behaviour will afaik get you banned from Wikimedia and Flickr but is regrettably legal so it makes it extra important to get it right.
4 Likes
Thanks for the reminder to finally get around to switching all my photos to CC-BY. I never quite figured out a good workflow for manually adding them to Wikimedia, nor do I really know which ones are likely to be needed, so hopefully someone will do something with some of them. :)
2 Likes
Thank you so much!
Yes, you are technically correct here. And I agree it’s an important note. The main gist — which is what I was offering — is that you “give appropriate credit” in accordance with the license. That’s the beauty of CC licenses: You don’t need to ask for permission.
Here’s what the Creative Commons folks say, exactly:
For CC BY, credit for their work and acknowledgement of the license; for the other licenses, only a few conditions on how the work may be reused.
See also: Overview of CC BY 4.0 license & the detailed attribution comparison chart for current and past versions of the license
Even for CC BY-SA, it’s primarily the name of the author and acknowledgement of the license, as you can see on this example courtesy of Wikipedia:
https://species.wikimedia.org/wiki/Euxoa_hollemani#/media/File:Euxoa_hollemani.jpg
That was an important issue, but the core issue should not be as widely applicable to media on iNaturalist. Part of the problem was that Flickr allows users to apply old versions of the license to current media. The CC 2.0 licenses include a harsher term for inadvertent violations, which was exploited as a business model, than the current 4.0 version:
As Doctorow explains, the primary issue of CC 2.0 licenses is that they include a clause that if a reuser violates the attribution agreement, even if it’s clearly by accident and not with malintent, the CC 2.0 license is terminated, thereby leaving the reuser open to legal threat.
Some Flickr users hope that reusers will incorrectly attribute CC 2.0 media, allowing the original creator to then target the reuser, sometimes with the threat of significant statutory damages. This goes against the guiding principle of Creative Commons.
Creative Commons addressed this with its CC 4.0 license, which guarantees users the same 30-day grace period that Flickr now requires.
https://petapixel.com/2023/04/05/flickr-fights-back-against-copyleft-trolls-with-updated-guidelines/
The Creative Commons organization has also been working on the issue of copyright trolls and principles of license enforcement.
3 Likes
Great news! Is there a way to see if our images have been used?
You should be able to go here and search for your (iNat) username:
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Special:MediaSearch?type=image
example:
2 Likes
Hello thanks for your response - I can only see random images which aren’t mine when I enter my iNat userid?? When I search with yours though I see lots of lovely images of insects etc. Maybe this means I have no images loaded?
You should quote your username to ensure you find this exact name:
Here is the query: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Special:MediaSearch?type=image&search="Martin487"
1 Like
cool thanks again!
And if you don’t want to have that license apply to all, but only some, you can change individual licenses manually from the “Edit” page of the respective observation.
This topic was automatically closed 60 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.