Platform(s): website Description of need: There are often multiple species in an observation. This is common with plants and parasites like galls/leafminers/fungi. People frequently seem confused when you request they duplicate an observation, they will often not don’t do it, or do it poorly (for …

@tiwane https://help.inaturalist.org/en/support/solutions/articles/151000169931-can-i-identify-multiple-taxa-per-observation-what-if-my-photo-has-a-flower-and-a-cool-bug- This needs updating with - no need to ID as Life. Use the new DQA for more than 1 subject. I was hoping that question would t…

I routinely encounter multiple species per observation. I always downgrade the ID, leave a boilerplate comment, and move on. The comment is brief and general: Multiple photos, multiple species. Can you split this observation? Thanks! If there were a help page for this, I would include it in the …

I do a lot of sound IDs, and I’d support the “Request Duplicate” button just for the many sound recordings in which multiple species are singing. I have a text replacement to suggest that the OP duplicate the observation, but only a few follow through.

I would find that confusing, as an observer. On at least one occasion I inadvertently added an unrelated photo to an OBS, and it was pointed out to me in a comment by an IDer - something along the lines of “the organism in photo 3 is different from the organism in photos 1 and 2. You should make a s…

Let’s hope that a “multiple-species observation” (with different organisms in different photos) won’t get duplicated (all photos duplicated, making 2 “multiple-species observations”). Such a confusion would be even worse.

For multiple species each with their own photo https://help.inaturalist.org/en/support/solutions/articles/151000171680-what-do-i-do-if-the-observation-has-multiple-photos-depicting-different-species- ~ We have a new (since February) DQA - Evidence related to a single subject But this thread is f…

You can duplicate an observation and just delete the extra photos. I’ve done it. It’s not hard at all. I prefer that than a button that will select only one picture . What if the subject is in 3 pictures? I’ve had observations where there were three different bombus, so I duplicated it twice and t…

While this seems like a decent solution and not one I’d feel confused by, I admit that new users often have struggles that are hard for experienced users to fathom. But I do think some kind of UI flow should be implemented to address or mitigate the number of observations logged that have several ph…

My idea has mutated a few times on this. In the past I really wanted a “Request Observation Split” that behaved the same way. Maybe there is a clever way combine that idea in here.

Add a 'Request Duplication' button

Feature Requests

tiwane June 9, 2024, 6:16am 2

I’m not sure if I’d want this, but I find the idea intriguing.

3 Likes

Topic		Replies	Views
Revisiting duplication of another user's observation General	33	749	December 2, 2024
Duplicate observation of another user Feature Requests	5	1131	September 5, 2019
Duplicate Photos in the Web Uploader Feature Requests web	17	2275	April 14, 2020
What is the appropriate response/action for a user uploading multiple duplicate images, organisms? General question	25	3429	September 17, 2021
How can you treat multiple observations that depict the same individual? General	31	1229	September 28, 2024

Add a 'Request Duplication' button

Related topics