There’s a nice, clear blue button at the top of the page for logging in, but not for logging out. Why? It seems strange that I have to hunt around in a menu to find such a basic feature. And to make matters even worse, it’s implemented as a text link at the bottom of the menu - which makes it hard to pick out from everthing else. At the very least, there should be a small log-out button at the top-right of the menu.
4 Likes
I think the log out button is okay; in fact, iNat uses the setup that most websites use. That is, you click on your profile icon, and at the very bottom is a “log out” of “sign out” option. I don’t see anything out of the ordinary.
4 Likes
Menus which include dynamic content should have all the control buttons at the top, so that they are easily discoverable. This is how major websites like Stack Exchange work. It is also very common to see a prominent log out button at the top of the page. Most security-conscious websites (such as online banks) have this, as well as major websites like Wikipedia.
It’s okay to have the log out button at the bottom of a profile menu, so long as the menu is relatively small and has fixed content. But the iNat menu is clearly not like that, so adding a small logout icon at the top right would be a definite improvement.
1 Like
@bazwal I totally agree. I hadn’t even noticed the log-out button until @ianhearn pointed it out. It should be at the top.
1 Like
Agree. Button should not scroll off the bottom of the screen.
Also, the forum could use a button that links to iNat. iNat interface easily leads you to the forum in a few places. Would be nice to be able to get back.
1 Like
I agree with Bozwal: you shouldn’t have to hunt around for a log out button. It should be as easy to find as the log in button. I noticed the same issue myself, but have never commented on it until now.
1 Like
The Discourse co-founder seems to disagree, so I don’t think this one is going to change.
codinghorror: Logout is a rare action for users to take, so putting it behind two clicks or taps isn’t a problem.
It was too prominent in its previous location, if anything, so this is more correct.
1 Like
On this analysis, since people rarely use fire alarms, they should be hidden out of sight.
Most users spend more time on other sites, which means they will generally prefer the current site to work in more or less the same way. If the current site meets their existing expectations, they can become productive more quickly by simple transferrence of skills. It’s a very common pattern for logout/exit buttons to be placed at the bottom of top-level menus (e.g. File > Quit), so many users will be frustrated if they can’t find them there. The alleged rarity of the action is irrelevant.
Probably. I mean, it’s not like prominent figures in software development ever get things wrong 
1 Like
This topic was automatically closed 60 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.