How to monitor and maintain the quality of your iNat contributions

Uploading stuff to iNat is great, but it’s also important to monitor and maintain the ongoing quality of your contributions. Here’s a few things I do to make sure that happens, and I hope you’ll find it useful!

++++++++++

I’m going to use myself as the example here - for all the links I post, simply replace my username with your own in the URL to view yours.

Casual observations:
It’s a good idea to check your casual grade observations every so often to make sure they are all ones you intended to be casual. There are several different ways that observations might become casual grade without you realizing.

I find it easiest to review these in Identify mode:
https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/identify?reviewed=any&quality_grade=casual&user_id=graysquirrel&place_id=any

Generally, the reason an observation is casual can be found in the Data Quality tab on the right.

In this example, since Wisteria is a commonly cultivated plant in my area, iNat has automatically added a vote for “not wild”. Although I countervoted this, because the seed is sprouting on its own, another user is also of the opinion it should be cultivated (fair enough, it’s a gray area). If you click on the little numbers, you can see the usernames of who voted. I’ve blacked it out for privacy here, but I could tag or message the person and explain why I feel it’s wild and ask them to change their vote. I could also tag some other user and ask them to add a “wild” vote to counter it out.

Sometimes people make mistakes and mark something they didn’t mean to, or misinterpret a photo, or just have a different opinion on what qualifies as wild. However, every so often someone will mark stuff casual out of retaliation for some perceived slight - if you’re a curator or someone who submits a lot of flags, you may want to check your observations a bit more often than others do.

Checking for flagged content:
There are a lot of unresolved flags, especially from back before people were told not to flag duplicate observations. Go to this link: https://www.inaturalist.org/flags
You’ll see the interface in the image below. Check all the boxes under “Reason”, type your username into the “content author” box, and hit “Filter.” If there are any unresolved flags on content you’ve created, you’ll see it there.

Maverick IDs
Bear in mind that just because your ID is a maverick doesn’t necessarily mean you are wrong - don’t let the peer pressure get to you, but it may be worth taking a second look to see if you still stand by your ID.
https://www.inaturalist.org/identifications?user_id=graysquirrel&category=maverick

Reviewing your old IDs
Have you ever felt confident about a species, done a bunch of IDs, and only later realized there were lookalikes you didn’t know about, and you probably misidentified a bunch of observations? I know I certainly have!

Fortunately, there’s a way to go back and find those old IDs so you can check them. You can use “ident_user_ID=” and “ident_taxon_ID=” to filter for observations that you have applied an ID to, and that have had an ID of that particular taxon applied to them. It’s not foolproof, because it doesn’t mean you were the one who applied the ID of that taxon, but it narrows it down considerably.
You can modify the URL below to fit your needs:
https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/identify?reviewed=any&quality_grade=needs_id%2Ccasual%2Cresearch&order=asc&verifiable=any&ident_taxon_id=48225&ident_user_id=graysquirrel&place_id=any

This example shows observations which I have applied an ID to at some point, and which have had an ID of “California Poppy” applied to them. Just replace “graysquirrel” with your user name and “48225” with the taxon ID number you want. (To get the number, just search for the taxon in iNat, go to the taxon page, and it’s the number that shows up in the URL).

Checking for spam flags
Sometimes the iNat spam filters catch something they shouldn’t, or someone accidentally marks something as spam. Although the spam flags are generally resolved very quickly, I’ve noticed that sometimes people’s observations don’t get properly re-indexed afterward, resulting in a hidden “spam” tag that keeps them from showing up in searches. If any observations show up for you in this search, all you need to do is change something to force a re-index (the easiest way is to just click and then unclick the “captive” checkbox) and that should clear it out.

Again, just replace “graysquirrel” with your own username in the following URL: https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/identify?reviewed=any&quality_grade=needs_id%2Cresearch%2Ccasual&spam=true&verifiable=any&user_id=graysquirrel&place_id=any

Pre-Maverick Observations (Thanks Diana!)

72 Likes

Thank you this was quite helpful. I found a couple of obs that had become incorrectly casual.

It struck me that it would actually be helpful to be notified if someone adds a “not wild” DQA vote… Or does this happen and I just missed it?

7 Likes

Checking for mavericks was a very useful tip- thank you for that.

3 Likes

Can I add the Pre-Mavericks? 2 against 1, you need to decide - are the 2 who agree right, or is the Proud Maverick the right one? 413K obs waiting patiently.
iNat’s Mavericks are already RG, so ‘your wrong ID’ is untidy, but doesn’t affect RG.
We have changed our Pre-Maverick rules. Anything Family or below will get picked up by specialists as they do their taxon sweeps.
We catch the broader IDs - so
Kingdom Disagreement to Life from typos or ‘beetle or daisy’ or homonyms.
Or all the levels between Kingdom and Family for similar reasons.
https://www.inaturalist.org/projects/pre-maverick
Correcting your Pre-Mavericks can make a difference - especially if it is now Family or below and caught by the filters that taxon specialists have set.
https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/identify?user_id=graysquirrel&project_id=156949&place_id=any
Since it is a project it can be used as a filter

3 Likes

This does not generate a notification, though it has been requested.

4 Likes

Thanks, that’s a great one as well! I’ve quoted your comment in my post to add it. (Also, thanks for helping to set up that project - I use it regularly as part of my IDing process)

1 Like

Does the URL need a ?reviewed=true in there to be useful to the observer, since they already reviewed their own observations?

1 Like

What would be really cool is to have a feature that does all of this checking for you and provides recommendations on responses.

4 Likes

If I replace graysquirrel with my name - the URL works for me -
No matching observations.

Since the CV updates about a thousand sp each month - there may well be new Suggested to consider.

1 Like

Check if your observations uploaded without coordinates
https://www.inaturalist.org/observations?place_id=any&project_id=no-coordinates-simple-checker&subview=table&user_id=graysquirrel&verifiable=any

Sometimes it happens when internet connection fails during upload.

These observations would be Casual though and could be found on the first graysquirrel’s link.

3 Likes

Is there a running list of CV additions that we can maybe query our old observations against?

No - just the one list which is active now.
There are links in each monthly blog post

https://www.inaturalist.org/blog/105731-new-computer-vision-model-v2-19-with-over-2-000-new-species

1 Like

I threw together this web app in an AI coding platform based on this post. I tried to pull all these considerations together, just enter your username. Curious if it’s helpful and what you think or if anyone has any suggestions:

https://inaturalist-obs-quality-tool.replit.app/

6 Likes

looks handy! The flagged content link just takes me to the generic flag page including all flags

1 Like

Have bookmarked to come back to later.
Thank you for including our Pre-Mavericks.
@jeanphilippeb

2 Likes

This is super awesome, thank you for putting it together!!

1 Like

Yes, that’s great!

I get that many flags (for taxa, for observations) in my list.
It seems I am not related to these flags, so something is likely wrong in the URL:
https://www.inaturalist.org/flags?content_author=jeanphilippeb

Yes, it just sends you to the generic flag page for right now.

I took this down for the time being. Still learning how to use this platform I deployed it on. Thanks for anyone checking it out

2 Likes

Very, very informative. i had no idea I could check these things. Fixed up a few things and understand a lot more about iNat. Thank you!

2 Likes