What Are People's Favorite Type of Mushroom(s)?

Ah,@jasonhernandez74, thank you for reminding Huitlacoche. I am so fascinated by uses of specific fungi and fungi-like organisms in Mexican cuisine, such as Huitlacoche and Caca de Luna. Would like to try them one day.

4 Likes

And yes, as a true mycophile, forgot about visual. Well, Phallaceae go without competition when it comes to phantastic forms (smell not included). Hiericium and Exidiopsis effusa are great, too. But then, in my country mushrooms are in general considered as flowers of the forest (especially in southern Lithuania) and appearance of fluffy white anamorphic Pezizales on soil is termed ‘flowering soil’ and considered a good sign of approaching yield of mushrooms, especially boletes.

4 Likes

from ordinary mushrooms, I would say that these are definitely champignons and porcini mushrooms

3 Likes

Wow, I didn’t know the Eastern Jack-o-lantern was bioluminescent. I’ll have to check for the ones that grow in my neighborhood every autumn.

3 Likes

To eat, Armillaria gallica of course! They’re a traditional Cherokee/Appalachian food around here, called “slicks,” and are some of the first wild mushrooms I foraged, cooked, and ate independently as a kid. Fried in butter over a campfire, you get to know why they’re called “honey mushrooms.” In late October/November, there’s really not that much they can be confused with due to the sheer numbers in which they pop out of the ground in the mountains. Also, their life history is completely insane.

A. gallica has a swollen base, scale-like projections on the cap, and an ornate membranous ring in it’s prime, so it’s definitely not an ugly mushroom either. Hydnum, Craterellus, and Cantharellus are also delicious. For vegans (even though I’m not one myself), I highly recommend barbequed or deep-fried Laetiporus cincinnatus. That’s a meal not easily forgotten, and it tastes remarkably like (drumroll): chicken!

Hoping to try some Lactarius fragilis (Southeastern Candy Cap) this upcoming season.

3 Likes

Someone once made a post about “Chicken Lips” and now I really want to find one!
https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/348808-Leotia-viscosa

I personally don’t know a lot about mushrooms. I once was out with a mushroom-savvy friend who found an enormous “Chicken of the Woods” and she shared it with me. I was skeptical, so I cooked a tiny amount and tried it. It was delicious! I waited a decent amount of time and when I did not die, I immediately cooked up the rest and made the best fried “chicken” sandwich ever.

My favorite personal observation of a mushroom is here:
https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/62354218
My daughter said “It looks like an apple pie!”

1 Like

I’ve always been particularly fond of bolete mushrooms for some reason.

1 Like

Ophiocordyceps sinensis Am not sure I can categorize this as my favorite. But it’s impact on himalayan mountain communities have been tremendous. Between 2000 and 2018 the collecting of this from the high alpine zone ( 3500 to 5000 metres) by 1000’s of collectors has changed their lives, the local economy, But has also been greatly detrimental to the ecology of these fragile ecosystems. It was somewhat of a “Gold rush” with similar dynamics.

The Morel mushroom is a favourite edible of the community where I live,

However my favourite wild edible Mushroom I don’t have a name for - found in the alpine region - preferring to grow on dung - large almost rectangular and white. When picked at the correct time is almost like a block of “Indian” Cottage Cheese.

2 Likes

The fly agaric is indeed a picturesque mushroom, a very pretty fairy-tale fungus.

I ate one once, back in the crazy 1960s. The people with me told me I would see God for sure. I didn’t.

I did not hallucinate at all, although I got rushes like nicotine rushes and eventually I threw up. But for almost a year afterwards, whenever I shut my eyes, I could watch brightly colored and very entertaining animation created by my own brain, whereas normally I see nothing when I close my eyes. Eventually the animations all faded to pastel tones, and then disappeared.

Apparently what compounds are present in the fly agaric vary enormously according to where it grows.

3 Likes

We have Shaggy Manes pop up in our yard every fall, and they are delicious when fresh. The deer like them, too.

1 Like

That is correct. Doses of A. muscaria that will cause really serious problems may vary very widely in different geographical regions. Judging from the reports, A. muscaria is less toxic in colder climates. Though the “recreational effect” seems to to be less varying.

1 Like

I find the Australian Craypot Stinkhorn the most fascinating of fungi. Watching one unfurl and take on its basket shape is just amazing. And they’re such a bright red colour. Unfortunately, the smell is a bit of a deterrent to making lengthy observations.

2 Likes

Sounds delicious! In California, there are also very desirable Boletus and others. My family tells stories of my great-grandmother from Lithuania who knew what to gather in the woods of New York even after moving here. The knowledge wasn’t passed down, but I’ve took a little mushroom workshop last year that was fun. Now one of my favorite mushrooms is an edible Amanita (of course some in the Genus are toxic).

2 Likes

Ah, this is sad… It would be so interesting if the knowledge was passed and to see how it evolved with different fungus species (compared to European). But this is very interesting what you say about edible Amanitas. This is comparable to Southwestern Europe (viz. Amanita cesarea). In Eastern Europe no Amanitas are ever collected for food. Not even edible ones (A. caesarea does not occur there).

2 Likes

Yes, I wish the foraging knowledge had been passed down. :)

There are similar looking toxic Amanita species to the edible species, but as with anything else, once you learn the difference, it is not too difficult to tell them apart. I would not recommend trying without a little training and confirmation from an expert.

Currently in the woods here, people are foraging for Morels, and in the Fall, the Golden Chanterelle are popular, but I think the species from Oregon is better tasting than the California species.

1 Like

My favorite fungi to eat is probably lion’s mane, which can be cultivated - https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/69439176

… or lobster mushroom (2 fungi species! Hypomyces lactifluorum is the parasitic brightly-colored one that brings the flavor, and its hosts, milk-caps or brittlegills, bring the body & texture) https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/59192136

… this following a clear pattern of me being a long time vegetarian who never really liked land-animal meat but was alright with seafood. Both of these cook up to be seafood reminiscent, especially in texture, to me.

But I haven’t tried all that many wild fungi you can eat yet! I’ve been inspired to look into it lately because of seeing presentations by chefs & foragers on safely finding and eating wild mushrooms. A site with a lot of recipes is https://foragerchef.com/mushrooms-2/

My favorite fungi I have seen someone else observe include Golden Coincap - Cyptotrama chrysopepla for its beauty & the fun I had identifying it with help from other WI myco society members in this observation - https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/61011375

I have also really enjoy the mysterious ones, that make you wonder “is this a fungus?”, like hazel woodwart - https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/65283006 where myco-microscopy really shines in helping us identify them

And to give it up to the unknowns, there is this crust fungus - https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/68255323 which is stunning, but I have very little idea where to start with identifying it, for now.

My favorite fungi I have observed include Holwaya mucida, on account of it being so small & also having interesting biology. https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/126908-Holwaya-mucida

And what might be Jafnea semitosta, a fungi species that has the distinction of the largest fungal genome sequenced and reported as of 2017 - https://www.jstor.org/stable/44853684?seq=1
https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/61117794

So many cup-shaped fungi are both bizarre (in a good way) and gorgeous - https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/59290124

If you like purple fungi, here are a few with various levels of violet, including the species you name -

Cortinarius violaceus, Violet Webcap - https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/124344-Cortinarius-violaceus

Cortinarius iodes , Viscid Violet Cort - https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/154583-Cortinarius-iodes

Cortinarius traganus Gassy Webcap - https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/58676-Cortinarius-traganus

Cortinarius porphyroideus, Purple Pouch - https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/127053-Cortinarius-porphyroideus

Lepista nuda, Blewit - https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/351380-Lepista-nuda

Laccaria amethystina, Amethyst Deceiver - https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/55899-Laccaria-amethystina

Mycena pura, Lilac Bonnet - https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/63473-Mycena-pura

Russula cyanoxantha, Charcoal Burner - https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/194437-Russula-cyanoxantha

Tylopilus plumbeoviolaceus, Violet Gray Bolete - https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/146681-Tylopilus-plumbeoviolaceus

Gymnopus iocephalus - https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/340976-Gymnopus-iocephalus Is at times purple.
…no common name. I suppose we could make a common name up. Translating the binomial, we get Barefoot Io’s Head. Didn’t “translate” Io because as far as I can tell, that is the mythological figure and not a root part. Weird name, might have to work on it. I found on the wikidata page for G. iocephalus a name for it listed in Chinese, 锈盖裸脚伞, which just putting it into machine translation gets “Rusty Umbrella”. Sounds good to me.
According to an article in this - https://www.psms.org/sporeprints/SP457.pdf - they can have a distinctive smell, possibly sauerkraut, gunpowder, or onion/garlicky, depending on who you ask.

And for non-mushroom shaped fungi,

Trichaptum bioforme, Violet-toothed Polypore, https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/125705-Trichaptum-biforme

Clavaria zollingeri, Violet Coral Fungus - https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/126160-Clavaria-zollingeri

Ramariopsis pulchella, Lilac Coral Fungus - https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/352201-Ramariopsis-pulchella

& Clavaria schaefferi, which we might call Pink Coral Fungus, while pink, does sometimes look purple - https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/701942-Clavaria-schaefferi

In crust fungi, Punctularia atropurpurascens, Violet Crust, https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/514081-Punctularia-atropurpurascens & if you look at Similar Species there you can see at least 3 more.

If you were interested in the wide range of fungal pigments themselves,
https://www.agriculturejournals.cz/publicFiles/37205.pdf
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5479939/

1 Like

The “dog poop” ones might be
Daldinia concentrica, King Alfred’s Cakes - https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/121714-Daldinia-concentrica
Exidia glandulosa, Black Witch’s Butter - https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/55568-Exidia-glandulosa
Kretzschmaria deusta, Brittle Cinder - https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/128051-Kretzschmaria-deusta
…or perhaps a relative.

Or, a slime mold rather than an actual fungus! Like the brown/grey examples of Wolf’s Milk - https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/47680-Lycogala-epidendrum

That’s a lot of information, I appreciate it

Well, that was fun to look through those! In my recollection, it looked more like the Brittle Cinder than the others.