What is the one thing you wish you could do on iNaturalist?

See https://forum.inaturalist.org/t/select-a-pinned-location-on-the-edit-page-for-already-uploaded-observations/3626/4

Looks like you have already created a Feature Request for that here:
https://forum.inaturalist.org/t/create-filter-option-in-user-interface-to-exclude-species-youve-observed/5790

2 Likes
  1. The ability to crop photos in the upload screen would save me SO much time, especially when I have 5 different things in 1 photo, and have to crop and save 5 versions on my PC before I upload.

  2. It’s easy to find the most commonly-observed species in an area, but I’d love to be able to see the LEAST observed species - both so I can look for more of them myself, and to check for erroneous IDs of things not actually found in the area.

  3. In similar vein as above, would like to be able to see what organisms are in the range map of an area but have not yet been observed there.

2 Likes

How is number 3 different than going to the checklist for a place and choosing unobserved. For instance
https://www.inaturalist.org/check_lists/7219-Ontario-Check-List?q=&view=photo&taxon=&observed=f&threatened=any&establishment_means=any&occurrence_status=not_absent&rank=species&taxonomic_status=active&commit=Filter

The challenge of course is maintaining the checklists, but those are certainly the most complete accounting of species distribution the site has.

1 Like

Number 2 sounds really interesting and speaks right to my competitive nature :) I like it!

Is there a way to do that on the mobile app? That’s what I use to upload/post.

No, not on the website either. But on the website explore function in species view so long as you are sufficiently filtered be it by taxonomy, geography, date whatever to be below 500 species, you can just scroll to the bottom of that page

1 Like

If you are referring to the ability to create and select pinned locations, no, I think that is only currently available as part of the web uploader. Might be worth a feature request to ask for similar functionality in the mobile apps.

Yes, sorry, I meant pinned locations. There are a lot of very noticeable differences between the mobile and desktop apps, why is that?

I can’t speak for the developers, but I think it is safe to say that there is a whole lot more functionality on the website (= desktop app) than could ever be packed into the mobile app and have it remain remotely usable as such. So it is streamlined to the most needed functions, which tend to center around capturing and posting observations real-time, and basic searches and interactions with other observations on the site. But it never hurts to ask for something new!

That said, I’ll just mention for general information that the Forum is currently not accepting new feature requests specific to the iPhone app IF the feature is already available on the Android app, as updates to the iPhone app are already a priority:

2 Likes

Didn’t know you could do that - thanks! I revise that wish to 'Make it EASIER to…" ;)

I’m not too familiar with checklists, to be honest. Are they automatically created, or user-generated? The one for my Northern California county shows ostriches, for some bizarre reason.
https://www.inaturalist.org/check_lists/2062-Sonoma-Check-List?commit=Filter&establishment_means=any&observed=f&occurrence_status=not_absent&page=1&q=&rank=species&taxon=&taxonomic_status=active&threatened=any&view=photo

They are in fact both, they can be enabled to auto generate based on observations, but users can also manually add things.

Some kind of thing to help me describe why I choose an ID. Right now it is a nice big empty space where you can type anything. But in my brain its like “I recognise that from the shape of the part under the flower, but what do you call that part under the flower again? Damn memory failing me.”

1 Like

I would like a link from the forum to the observations page for each user. People will mention something about their observations, and then I want to see their observations, but I have to copy their name and then search iNat. …unless I am missing an easier way.

2 Likes

I agree with you! I can sometimes see the difference between say, two species, but I often don’t have the vocabulary to explain why. Like “This one has a different face from that one. Oh, how is it different? Uhhhhhhhhhhhhhh…”

By clicking your icon in the upper right, at the top right of the drop down box there is a cog shape that gives preferences.



In Preference there is a setting on our iNatForum profile that enables us to add a website. Some of us have selected to add our profile page on iNaturalist which gives access to our observation, species, identifications, journal posts, lists, followers, followings, favourite taxa, profile statement, calendar, favourites, projects, profile statement, when we joined, when we were last active, and our name if we so select. This link will show up when you select our name or icon in a reply and the User Card shows up with various information. I am quite comfortable with this being a personal choice rather than an automatic link. I’m not sure if the guidelines stipulate that the same public identity be used on both platforms.

4 Likes

Thank you, very helpful with the pictures.

1 Like

I wish I could call up a list of all my journal posts showing the titles, in addition to simply by the month.

Is that possible?

You can at least search by word on the IDs page: key in ctrl F, and a box appears where you can type in the word you want. Then use the little arrows in the box showing number of occurrences to hop through them.
Unfortunately, you have to do this on each page of observations,since they aren’t continuous.

All, after some discussion among the Forum Moderators, we have decided that your wishes and ideas would be better served if we closed this topic, and instead redirected everyone to:

  • General Topics (Discussion or questions about iNaturalist and how it works. How can I do X? Is it possible to do Y? etc.), or
  • Feature Requests (Please add/modify this capability on iNaturalist)

Be sure to search existing topics first before posting a new one, to make sure something hasn’t already been discussed or requested. If it has, please join in there instead. But otherwise, please feel free to start new topics for the ideas already brought up in this thread.

That will help to better organize your thoughts and ideas, and prevent them from getting lost in a topic like this thread, which is going in so many different directions at once.

Just to round out the other possible categories for your posts:

  • Bug Reports (iNaturalist isn’t working right, and I’m pretty sure it isn’t my computer/browser/phone)
  • Forum Feedback (the Forum isn’t working right, questions about how the Forum works, etc.)
  • Tutorials (I’ve learned how to do this useful thing in iNaturalist, and here’s how) – check existing Tutorial topics for the kind of content that fits there
  • iNaturalist.org (Please help me identify this. Species is missing. Species name or other information is wrong. Identification is wrong.) - for these issues, post or identify an observation, or flag a taxon for curation
  • iNaturalist.org journal (each user has their own!) - I saw this neat organism here yesterday. Please join me for this upcoming get-together. My recent trip to the Galapagos Islands. etc.
  • Nature Talk - nature-related topics not directly related to iNaturalist or to any of the other categories above.

Thank you all for keeping the great ideas and discussion going in our community, and for helping us to keep it all well-focused on the Forum.

4 Likes