When would a leaf be considered "dead"?

I’m not sure that it is possible to avoid these kinds of discussion points. You specified, “as technical and scientifically logical as possible.” Malcolm’s reply was that: “The animal may be dead but its organs and cells may individually survive a bit longer.” This is pertinent to your question in that the same can apply to a leaf – death in the organismal sense occurs before death in the sense of cessation of cellular activity.

I had a similar question some years ago when we had a cat put down. I asked the vet, “How do we know when she’s gone?” The fact that the cat had gone completely limp did not tell me whether she was gone, because a cat under anesthesia would also go completely limp. What I was trying to ask – I now realize – was where is the point of no return? The difference between mostly dead and all dead (if you remember “The Princess Bride”)? Dead would seem to be – in its most basic, biologial sense – the point at which it is impossible to revive the organism. A cat under anesthesia, but not dead, can be revived; whereas a dead cat cannot, even though some cellular activity may still be ongoing.

If that is our working definition, then Anna Katrin explained it best: “the point of death for the leaf would be once those layers are completed and the leaf has been cut off entirely from the tree’s vascular system” – because that would be the point at which the leaf cannot be “revived.”

3 Likes

This topic was automatically closed 60 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.