Add "Captive" filter choice to Photo Browser options

Platform(s), such as mobile, website, API, other: web

URLs (aka web addresses) of any pages, if relevant: example https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/133310-Ixora/browse_photos?order_by=created_at&quality_grade=any&term_id=12&term_value_id=13

Description of need:

area of interest in example page

Feature request details:
After several years of successful Bioblitzes, there is a large bank of images of cultivated plants marked “not wild”. However, these images are not readily accessible to the casual user through the Photo Browser. For easy access, it would be great to add “Captive” to the pulldown where circled in the screenshot. (The filter is currently available through the Identify pane, but that introduces more of a learning curve just to see the pictures.)

A more accessible view of these plants could also incentivize Phenology annotation within the Captive dataset. That annotation could be useful later to help illustrate plant features to other people (such as bioblitz participants, or identifiers who are assisting) with a simple Photo Browser-based link.

Don’t forget to vote for your own feature request :)

Great idea!

I just realized this could make finding reference pics of certain individual “celebrity plants” during bioblitzes a lot easier too.

Since there’s an existing filter for quality grade would just added a casual option suffice?

I guess that would work assuming all the “weird things” that also go into casual (missing location, date etc) would not be bad to show as well?

There are valid data also on casual observations, I think that a way to filter out capitve individuals would be useful. On this regard, this option would be great for projects.

2 Likes

We need 3 categories on iNat
Wild

NOT Wild

DQA issues - broken obs of many sorts

3 Likes

Captive/cultivated status can be used as a filter on traditional projects. Grade (casual, research grade) can be used as a filter on collection projects, so this somewhat gets at captive/cultivated. I don’t know if there’s a way to specifically target captive/cultivated on collection projects though.

I made an issue to have “any” include observations with any data quality: https://github.com/inaturalist/inaturalist/issues/4186

Technically, “captive” isn’t a data quality grade, so it would have to be used in a different category and I think there are already plenty of filters there. So I’m going to close this request.

Just noting that we released the fix, so if you choose Any for Quality Grade, you’ll see photos from observations of all Quality Grade types.

3 Likes