Compare iNat Suggested IDs

Is there a way to compare the list of suggested IDs that iNat makes when clicking in the “Suggest an Identification” text box?

I sometimes want to compare suggestions that iNat makes when I’m looking at a plant that has similar look-alikes that are not of the same genus, or when I’m feeling pretty sure the observer has made an incorrect suggestion and I want to compare the iNat suggestions (not compare what was suggested).

Currently, to do this, I have to do a lot of back and forth by clicking “view” on several items in the list. Is there a way to get the Compare box to come up showing all of the options in the suggestion list?

I hope this question makes sense (and that there is a way to do this that I don’t know about).

Thanks!

As a clarifying question, are you trying to compare the list of CV suggested ID’s between two different observations? Or compare suggested taxa?

If I understand correctly on what you want to do, it might be easier to accomplish on desktop, where you can open multiple tabs and switch between them easily.

On mobile, I’ve been comparing suggestions the same way you do.

2 Likes

Probably not what you’re looking for, but here’s a workflow that utilizes the window tiling feature in Windows or Mac, any browser, and some minor digital elbow grease. This works better if you’ve a high-resolution monitor without “scaling” enabled or just a large monitor.

The idea is to go from this:

To this:

To do that, you first duplicate the tab. Every browser has this option. Chrome has it as “Duplicate” and Firefox has it as “Duplicate Tab”:

After you duplicate the tab, right click and select “Move Tab > Move to New Window”. In Chrome, it’s simply “Move tab to new window”.

The new window will cover your original.

In Windows, click and hold the new window from the title bar to the right side (or left) of your screen. When you see a gray box (or some other color), let go of the mouse button.

Note: on Mac, this is called window tiling, and I believe it can be done by clicking and holding the top of the window and dragging the window while you hold the option key.

Anyway, after you drop the window, on the left side, you can select the original window.

Now on the right side, scroll to the “Suggest an Identification” text box, click on it, and when you see the suggestions you can do Ctrl + Click on “View” to open the suggestions as individual tabs in a few clicks:

After that, you can just go to whatever tab you want for your comparison, and hit “View More” for the photos:

And then you can browse individual photos or use the photo browser:

Now, the good thing about this is that the above is just the initial setup. After this, you can maximize your left window if you want. And if you need to do comparisons again, drag that window to the left to tile it, then duplicate the tab, then drag that tab to the right window, do some basic cleanup (close old tabs), and open the suggestions as tabs from the “Suggest an Identification” text box once again.

Anyway, it’s a bit unorthodox, but it’s worked for me in my limited range of knowledge.

4 Likes

Thank you for replying and trying to help me!

I am using a desktop so yes, View opens new tabs, but it is still cumbersome to go back and forth and harder to do a quick compare (side by side unless I pull the tab into a new window).

I’m trying to compare the iNat suggestions when I click the Suggest and ID textbox (see first photo below).

Here is an example of where I might want to use this (the observer selected a suggestion that I’m pretty sure is incorrect, but I’m not sure what IS correct so I want to compare the iNat suggestions…maybe not to suggest something different, unless I’m certain, but just to try and educate myself or just out of curiosity): https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/302152423

When I click in the “Suggest an Identification box,” I see the attached photo (I don’t want to have to click “view” on each of those to see them in a separate tab…I would like to see them all in a compare box on the right…it’s much faster).

And now, because I’ve chosen Dicots (since I don’t know what it is), I can’t compare or I see a HUGE list of unrelated plants (second photo).

Thank you. This is not exactly what I want to do (although might be okay…I’ll try it). I expect it is still more work because I have to click View on each one in the list to open them all and then tile and then close all of the new tabs after I’m done, etc. I’m on a macbook pro so not a huge screen. I would much prefer to have the option to use the Compare feature in iNat…from there, I can click on items that look close and view them in a separate tab.

I’m IDing a large number of things so something quick like the compare would make it easier. Sometimes I just choose to skip something because of the extra time involved (which is an okay solution, too). I was just hoping for something to make it easier when I have to (or want to) try and figure it out or just learn more about what might be in the photo.

Change the “Source” to “Visually Similar” in the Compare box:

7 Likes

That is a HUGE help. I did not know about that drop down. Thank you. It doesn’t work if the observer left the option blank (so there is no compare option), but I can put something in like dicots or vascular plants (or whatever) and then compare. Thank you!

3 Likes

On observations without an identification, you can still click Compare on the right side of the page next to where it says “Community Taxon”. If you use the Identify page, the Suggestions tab is always there as well.

3 Likes

Thank you. I didn’t realize that. I appreciate the extra information.

2 Likes

This topic was automatically closed 60 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.