assuming these photos were the same besides their subject matter, i’m not sure what to tell you. you could try recropping the photos from this same set and see if you get the same 2:18 result. if so, i guess there might be some difference between the 2 and the 18. otherwise, it would seem to be random or maybe based on differences in workflow.
At times like this, I often feel that computers and such like are more of an art than a science . This could, however, be the clue to understanding the cause of the problem. Things to maybe consider:
- were all the photos taken on the exact same device with the exact same settings?
- did you do anything else to these photos before you cropped them with Photos?
- did you do anything else to the images in Photos, such as changing the brightness, contrast etc.?
- were you doing anything else on the same computer at the same time? Did you have different programmes running?
And yes, try for repeatability.
You have my sympathy .
It’s been doing that to me more or less forever, before the new version. I just put in a non cropped picture too and get the data from that. It’s been through two desktops with two different windows versions. And it’s not consistent! Sometimes it keeps the metadata, sometimes it doesn’t, even in the same session (so same SD card, same camera, same everything). I’ve tried going slower, and cropping less of the photo, to see if that helps but I didn’t see any difference.
have you ever tried recropping a photo that retained its coordinates vs on that didn’t to see if you got the same retention or non-retention?
No, and I probably should have thought of that. Seems like something straightforward to test out next time
Just thought I should add an update. This issue was going to cause me problems as I was going away on a trip and I wouldn’t be able to easily keep track of where photos were taken.
I installed Irfanview, which is a nice small program that crops photos without removing location data. My observations done while travelling kept their locations, and I have kept my sanity by continuing to use it after returning home.
I have the same problem. I first saw it on a new laptop this Spring, running Windows 11. About a month ago, it showed up on my desktop, which has Windows 10 Home. Notably, while Windows offers the option of downloading the old version as Windows Photo Legacy, I’ve tried that on both PCs and the problem still occurs with that on both computers. Whatever Microsoft has done to break this feature, they’ve broken it on the “Legacy” version, too. :(
I’ve been following the work-around suggested above, of using the “save as” option when cropping a photo, so the uncropped version is still available with the GPS data.
I’ve downloaded IrfanView, too, but it doesn’t seem as easy to access the crop function as in Windows Photo. Maybe I’m just not familiar enough with it.
To crop in irfanview, draw a rectangle with your mouse (by holding down the mouse button while moving the mouse - you will see the lines creating the rectangle as you move it). When happy with the area inside the rectangle, go to the Edit menu, and choose Crop Selection.
Yes, keyboard options are available instead of menu commands. I don’t tend to use them because of the way I use my computer. I don’t have my hands anywhere near the keyboard most of the time.
Tried it after this last trip and it varied. I’m assuming it’s on my PC’s end and not on Inat’s end. Haven’t seen this with photos taken and edited on my iPhone either.