Some fungi are so delicate that it’s very difficult to photograph the underside without damaging the specimen. Is it acceptable to pluck up a mushroom so as to better photograph the underside? What’s the accepted practice?

It’s for you to decide, but generally yes, it is acceptable, those are fruiting bodies and you do a little to no harm getting those out, if you check regular ided photos they mostly include a series of plucked out specimen, like here: https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/3593069 Though surely y…

here’s a mention of a video that discusses how to observe mushrooms: [image] Not getting any IDs for my photos of insects and fungi For those interested in making your fungus (specifically mushroom) observations more identifiable on iNat, this video tutorial from @Leptonia is a great place to be…

Thank you. That was exactly what I thought but I’m still far from being experienced. Thanks for the rapid reply.

It’s a debate, but if you carry a small mirror on a stick you can use that to photograph the undersides without damaging the mushroom.

I had shown a hack with elastics, a pocket mirror, and chopsticks here for just that. https://forum.inaturalist.org/t/life-hacks-for-naturalists/4636/54

https://www.conservationevidence.com/individual-study/230#:~:text=Since%20harvesting%20fungal%20fruiting%20bodies,through%20the%20spread%20of%20mycelium Here’s a study that covers this in surprising detail :)

when I do pick a mushroom to better photograph or examine, I like to lend it a spore-spreading hand: I chuck it as high as possible. Maybe the brief flight helps with long-distance spore dispersal.

All of a sudden I am imagining field kits with Nerf Dog Tennis Ball Blasters included.

I think you guys are onto something. I often hang them in branches when it turns out I’m not eating that particular mushroom.

I would advise to pick a fruitbody. The mirror, etc. technicues will not allow to show necessary details and are largely useless. Besides, for many cap mushroom species change of the flesh (colour, its intensiveness, localization, etc.) are essential. Furthermore, if you have time and possibili…

Damage to specimens

General

jhbratton January 30, 2021, 10:08am 14

Yes, but in some cases, it is like an apple tree that only produces one apple in a decade.

Topic		Replies	Views
How do you view mushroom gills without breaking mushroom? Nature Talk question	12	1921	July 15, 2021
Mushroom Ethics General	25	1879	December 16, 2022
Hints for Photographers of Fungi Nature Talk	7	776	July 15, 2023
How to photograph mushrooms specifically for i.d.? Nature Talk	11	1324	August 19, 2024
With fall come mushrooms - what should we know? Nature Talk	15	732	September 30, 2023

Damage to specimens

Related topics