Intro and Noobie Question: How Many Observations of a Species?

Hi folks,

What a great app, what a good thing to be doing in general, and what good clean social-distancing-compliant fun.

I read an article about iNaturalist about a month ago and got the app, but just tried it today.

Looking forward to to cataloging our six acres in the North Georgia mountains, plus all the places I hike and bushcraft.

Anyway, my noobie question… How many observations of a given species in one general area are appropriate? Just one, to avoid giving a skewed impression of the population, or more than one to capture multiple views of the same species at different times of year?

Thanks!

6 Likes

Single individual can be posted each day. A species can be posted as many times as you find it, multiple times a day.

6 Likes

From https://www.inaturalist.org/pages/help#observations1

" Observations

  1. What is an observation?

Observations are the basic units of iNaturalist. An observation records an encounter with an individual organism at a particular time and location. This includes encounters with signs of organisms like tracks, nests, or things that just died. You should make separate observations for each separate critter you encounter. iNaturalist provides a place to add this information along with associated text, photos, and tags. If you revisit an organism, such as returning to a plant when it’s in bloom for additional photographs, you should make a separate observation because it was observed on a different date."

7 Likes

Also consider that if you return to it on the same day and it is substantially different then you can make it another observation… eg if it is a larvae and on returning you discover it has become a pupa, or a bird that was feeding when you saw it 3 hours ago but is now showing courtship behaviour.

As for how frequently you observe a species, it is completely up to you! Some people try to document every individual (often for select taxa), while others just make observations of things that are new to them or appear remarkable for some reason. Some will only make observations of things which they know the ID of, while others will make observations only of the things they don’t know so they can find out what they are!

9 Likes

@BradGad Welcome to the forum! I really hope you enjoy the iNat app, and the forum. As @Star3, @kiwifergus, and @melodi_96 said, it really doesn’t matter how many observations of a species, it is entirely up to you. :-)

6 Likes

@BradGad glad you have joined us on iNaturalist and here in the forum! I’ll just echo all the great answers above, and also note another discussion on the same topic that may be helpful:

https://forum.inaturalist.org/t/etiquette-for-posting-many-observations-of-the-same-species/9639

2 Likes

I’m also new to iNaturalist. I learned that we can upload more than one photo of a single organism to an observation, so if you have multiple photos (or sounds, I guess, though I haven’t tried that yet), you can add all of them to a single observation. For example, I have front and back photos of a single hawk–and having both views helped other users confirm a species for me.

As to how many photos: I don’t know if there’s a technical limit but I am trying to show different views, such as the front and back of that hawk, or close-up and wider views. I haven’t uploaded any trees yet, but it seems to me that a wide view plus close-ups of bark, buds, leaves, etc. would be helpful. I am avoiding redundant photos and just picking the best one.

Hoping some more experienced iNaturalist users will chime in to help us both.

6 Likes

As far as I am aware there is no numerical limit, there may be a ‘how much space do they take up’ one, but even then I am unaware of it. There are observations I know of with 20+ photos.

Technically as you note, the photos all should be of the same individual specimen, but you will find that is not strictly enforced.

6 Likes

I don’t know the technical limit to how many photos can be included in one observation, but you are absolutely right that having several photos of different parts of an organism can be very helpful in confirming an identification. For example, if I know that a particular fern can be told apart from a close relative by the placement of sori on the underside of the frond, I’ll take two photos: one of the overall fern and one close-up showing where the sori are on the underside.

Lynn Harper/MassWildlife

6 Likes

Thanks, Lynn, that clarifies it for me.

1 Like

Yes, for many plants it helps to have the leaves (top and bottom since the hairiness is often a character), bark, flowers, fruit, and overall appearance. Of course most of the time you can’t get all of those at once, especially flowers and fruit together, but more is always better. Same with insects, the more angles the better.

1 Like

Just to update there is now an active item in the Github list that would establish a limit of 20 pics per observation, so it appears this will be changing.

1 Like