Organisms with a very disjunct distribution: issues?

Some species, not currently divided in any subspecific taxa, have a very disjunct distribution with thousands miles separating the known present areas where they occur.
Two examples are Mesembryanthemum nodiflorum and M. crystallinum, both occurring EDIT: AS NATIVE in the Mediterranean basin, the Arabian area and in southern Africa. As regards, since Southern Africa is a known center of biodiversity for mesembs one could be allowed to wonder if plants growing in the extra-African populations are native or not.
Similar examples regard plants that were known as trans-Atalntic but eventually turned out to have been introduced in Europe.

Other examples possibly raising other issues?

1 Like

Distribution map of Mesembryanthemum nodiflorum according to POWO.

Why would Portugal be Introduced, while Spain is Native?

Xanthosia atkinsoniana in Australia. Two completely disjunct populations on opposite sides of the continent, thousands of kilometres apart. Evidence of a historically contiguous population or actually two cryptic species? No idea

8 Likes

Rhipsalis baccifera – range is Madagascar, Seychelles, Mauritius, Reunion, Sri Lanka.
All other Rhipsalis spp. – range is South America and into Costa Rica.
All other Cactaceae – range is in the Americas.

Rhipsalis baccifera is the only cactus native outside the Americas, and is endemic to islands of the Indian Ocean, which is the only ocean with no shore in the Americas.

7 Likes

Bromeliaceae… 3700 species known, all native in the Americas… Except for one, Pitcairnia feliciana, which is native to western Africa… Some very old relict I guess from when those two land masses were still one?

2 Likes

Any possibility of anthropogenic movement? Any known use by first peoples?

1 Like

none that I know of. Just an inconspicuous little herb

1 Like

Tame example: bigtooth maple http://dendro.cnre.vt.edu/dendrology/images/Acer%20grandidentatum/map.jpg

Start in central Texas (“Lost Maples”), jump to Guadalupe Mountains (about 400 miles in the car), north to Manzano Mountains near Albuquerque (another 300 miles by car), jump again to SE Utah or SE Arizona, then main population in northern Utah. Interesting relics of cooler climate in the West.

New Mexico has all kinds of mini examples, like our Rio Grande Cottonwood trees in Albuquerque are a subspecies of the eastern cottonwood http://dendro.cnre.vt.edu/dendrology/images/Populus%20deltoides/map.jpg

1 Like

Maybe both (or like @bobmcd suggested, a recent dispersal). In one sense they are already cryptic species, since unless and until there is gene flow between the two areas, they are already on separate evolutionary trajectories. Maybe just not for long enough to have fixed any visible differences yet.

4 Likes

I’ve driven the Nullarbor, those are two distinct/disjunct ranges but they didn’t have the biosecurity in the old days. We ate “border stew” a few times when crossing the various state borders…num…

1 Like

and America.
Distribution map on POWO.

and it is also our only indigenous to South Africa cactus. Very weird distribution.

violet countries in the map represent occurrences as non-native species

Fungus Chorioactis geaster is found only in Texas and Japan, and is believed to be native to both.

We have a few species here in the Southern Appalachian mountains that have disjunct occurrences in the coastal areas (e.g. BONAP map for Kalmia buxifolia) but not quite as dramatic in terms of distance as some of the other examples mentioned earlier in this thread. I think genetic studies are ongoing to determine what’s going on and how distinct they are on a genetic level.

Going back further into time, a lot of our Southern Appalachian plant species have Asian counterparts - a well-known and studied disjunction on genus level - they usually have evolved into sister species by now rather than still being considered the same. The explanation I’ve heard from colleagues studying biogeography is that these species were once spread throughout the entire northern temperate zone, but the ice ages pushed them up against the Alpes and to extinction in Europe while they could escape into southern refugia in Eastern North America and Eastern Asia and then recolonized those areas once the glaciers receded and diversified into our modern day sister species.

2 Likes

That reminds me that the tribe Cheloneae is entirely in North and Central America except for Pennelianthus frutescens http://naturelog.main.jp/plants124.html https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/785974-Pennellianthus-frutescens

Asplenium dalhousiae in the Himalayas and in southern Arizona and Mexico. Its status in North America seems tenuous and I don’t know of any recent records.

I am curious about Azure-winged and Iberian Magpies (used to be considered one species, Azure-winged Magpie. Genus Cyanopica