So which bird can you imitate?

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-10-26/nsw-far-south-coast-bird-calling-olympics/104521500

A very cute news item. My best bird call would be a rainbow pitta. My partner and I use it to attract each others attention when out and about. My partner does a very good whistling kite.

12 Likes

I can do a mourning dove :laughing:

5 Likes

American Bittern

1 Like

I can’t do it, and I’m not a bearder, but I remember @russjones in 2010? making a Screech Owl noise

(Megascops asio)

to call them in, and they came flying in, just like pets. It blew my mind!

5 Likes

I just watched the video. Those kids are amazing! Even though they imitated a lot of species with harsh and unpleasant calls (parrots, corvids, etc.). They did a great job!

I guess doing this in the field is a no-no now in birding circles, because you trick the bird into spending precious energy defending territory or whatever (defending it from you), so you’re disrupting natural behaviours?

3 Likes

Ecological literacy is at an all-time low now, so if you can do even a halfway recognizable voice impression of any animal (not just a bird), lots of people will think you’re amazing!

5 Likes

I can do Tengmalm’s owl (Boreal owl, Aegolius funereus) well enough to attract them. First time I was able to do it (I was 13), after my biology teacher taught the technique during our biology club’s overnight trip, I was thrilled. I had practiced it for two months. Gave a really strong feeling of connection with nature.

2 Likes

How are they harsh and unpleasant? They’re beautiful!

1 Like

I can’t do it, but I always enjoy doing curlew calls.
Doing pigeon coos always makes kids giggle as well : )

3 Likes

I used to be able to do the “whit whit” sounds turkeys make,when I worked for a park/farm. I thought it meant “food girl food girl”.

I make “chuck chuck” sounds when crossing a foot bridge across a piece of swamp. It seems to chill out the red winged black birds and maybe some perching birds.

3 Likes

Same! Also black-capped chickadee is really easy too.

Warblers are easy as well if you can whistle at the right octaves.

2 Likes

I can only imitate a human, but I do that FLAWLESSLY. However, I like to try American bittern and black sicklebill.

5 Likes

I can’t imitate any bird calls in a way that would convince another bird.
I would most like to convince the crows that I am one of them. But no matter how urgent and deep and raspy I make my “Caw! Caw! CAWs!” they take offense and flap off. I fear I am inadvertently saying something insulting. Or perhaps it is the mere fact that I have the audacity to try to speak to them at all, that offends them…

5 Likes

I can honk like a Canada Goose well enough that flying geese will turn their heads and look.

5 Likes

Mourning Dove and Great Horned Owl, both well enough that I get answers. I also used to do a passable Whipporwill, but I’m out of practice. Trying to learn Common Raven as well; they seem kind of amused by my attempts, and I have a feeling that I’m saying something like the corvid equivalent of “My hovercraft is full of eels.” :laughing:

3 Likes

I used to be able to do a pretty decent screech owl call. I stopped doing it because a couple of blue-gray gnatcatchers came out of some trees when I was hiking in the spring and doing the call. They were clearly upset. I don’t want to cause stress to the birds like that anymore.

4 Likes

I can do a pretty good Bullfrog!

As for birds, my best is a day-old Domestic Chicken. Not too bad at the Mallard, either.

3 Likes

Yes! The bullfrog is my best animal imitation! I did it once for some captive male bullfrogs, and they were NOT happy. They tried to challenge me through the glass :laughing:

2 Likes

The Dumetella carolinensis in my hometown taught me their language, and when I return to the same area they remember me. I’m better at the cat-sounding calls than their more complex songs, though. I’m also really good at cat cat noises for some reason, but believe it or not cats are not birds.

4 Likes

Eurasian collared dove. Its kinda rare in our locality. I’ve tried to fool people using the imitation, but it hasnt worked so far. :upside_down_face:

Imitation has fooled Merlin tho.

3 Likes