I think that you should be able to sync data between devices in the Seek application. This would be beneficial because as it stands now, switching to a new phone causes you to lose all your observations and data, and I’m sure people would be more motivated to go out and make observations if their observations were more permanent.
People have suggested using the iNaturalist app instead of Seek so that data is saved, but I think that the intuitive UI and gamification of Seek is a lot more enjoyable, and switching apps would also cause me to lose my current observations.
Does anybody else feel that this feature would improve their experience of Seek?
Welcome to the Forum! Don’t forget to vote for your own feature request!
4 Likes
I approved this feature request and meant to add some clarifications right afterward but got distracted. Sorry!
Here’s a previous statement I made about this kind of functionality.
As noted, Seek is really focused on privacy and not sharing information. So it’s unlikely we’d sync between devices if “sync” means that if you had Seek installed on two different devices they’d both instantly sync the same observations (and achievements) between them.
For the specific situation @jacobpants mentioned - getting a new device and wanting to transfer your existing observations to it - I think some sort of manual backup option is more likely. You could choose to back up your observations to some cloud storage and then, when you install Seek on your new device, you could download those from the backup. One issue, of course, is that Seek is built for privacy and iNat not storing your information, so uploading all this to iNat’s servers would be a bit antithetical to that.
What I think might work is just making sure Seek data is stored in backups of devices. iOS devices already do this. If you back up your iPhone/iPad to either iCloud to your computer and restore your new device from that backup, your Seek observations will be part of that backup. I recently lost my iPhone in San Francisco Bay and, when I restored my new phone from that older phone’s backup, all my Seek observations were in it, so in my experience it worked well.
I think doing this for Android is a bit more tricky (we’ve explored it a bit) but I’d love to see that happen. It’s a bummer to lose your observations just because you got a new phone.
5 Likes
Maybe some option of manually downloading and uploading a file with observations to a new account on you new device? Without storing it somewhere else
1 Like
Ağustos 2020 den beri Seek kullanıyorum. Android bir telefonum vardı. Yeni bir Android telefon aldım. Ne yazık ki eski gözlemlerim eski telefonumda kaldı. Keşke birleştirebilseydim.
1 Like
If you backup your Android device to Google Drive, your obserations should part of that backup, so if you move to a new device and restore from your Google Drive backup, they’ll come along with it. It’s worked so far with a small number of observations.
3 Likes
I’ve just successfully transferred my Seek user data (observations, challenges etc.) from an old Android to my new Android using the Helium app (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.koushikdutta.backup). Although Helium appears no longer able to transfer entire apps to the current Android versions (it hasn’t been updated since 2019), it is capable of successfully transferring the app data in isolation. If anyone would like details of how I transferred my data, let me know and I’ll post them here. Obviously, YMMV on your devices, account etc. so no guarantees
2 Likes
Seems to me like there could be the option just to export a list of every species you’ve identified and important such a list into the new phone’s Seek, which could then know the difference between a new species and a previously identified one (and know what badges etc. have been earned).
Yes, it wouldn’t have the photos and dates of observations, so it’s not ideal, but I don’t think there would be any privacy issues in just having a way to check off the things we’ve already IDed in a new device (I don’t really get the privacy issue of someone with 2 phones having the app sync between devices either, but I imagine there is one since others seem to get it). Anything is better than getting the “new species” response to everything and losing years of observations.
Honestly I probably would pay for Helium if I knew it would work, but hesitant to pay $5 for the level of confidence mikep17 presents.
2 Likes
I think it’s extremely discouraging for people not to be able to keep their hard-earned records.
According to @tiwane ‘s description, it is as if iNaturalist is the sync-able version of Seek. But it’s not. Seek, with its gamified features and rudimentary taxonomic functionality, cannot be fully replaced by iNaturalist, which to me functions more like a forum where you upload hard-to-identify species for experts’ help.
To me it felt like the developers do not care about their users’ needs as much as the developer’s own ideology of privacy. Users should be able to decide for themselves whether they want this privacy feature.
3 Likes
Some sort of manual export/import or sync function is absolutely essential to this app realising it’s full potential.
What is the point of saving observations if there is no way to permanently keep the data?
I can’t see how a well implemented sync function would compromise privacy in any way.
Please reconsider your approach here, I just started saving observations the other day, and made an account with the hope that doing so would sync or backup my observations, and was surprised to find this isn’t the case. If there is absolutely no future plans for this then there is no reason for me to save observations or engage in the community aspects of the app.
1 Like
Seek is designed for minors, it is gamified for that, iNat is a replacement of Seek for adults.
What would you consider that to be?
I’d be for functionality that will backup one’s obserations in order to move them to a new device, but not automatically syncing observations across devices.
What community aspects of Seek are you referring to? It doesn’t have any, it just allows you to post new observations to iNaturalist.
Seek is designed for minors, it is gamified for that, iNat is a replacement of Seek for adults.
I wouldn’t say that’s entirely accurate. Seek is designed for people who don’t want to/can’t use iNaturalist to engage with nature. iNat’s not for everyone (including some adults) - not everyone wants to share their data, not everyone wants to join a social network, and some people really want badges and challenges - so Seek is designed for those people.
3 Likes
Sure, I just didn’t want to overcoplicate the message, iNat has all, but badges, and then people can vote for better system of app “aims”, etc. on iNat if they want that.
1 Like
I just learned about Seek and INaturalist installed both and was incredibly excited.
Then I start using the apps for a few days.
Then I learn I can’t upload from google photos to Seek.
Then I learn I can’t upload from INaturalist to Seek
Then I learn I’ll lose Seek data on new phone
Then I learn I can’t sync Seek between devices
Then I see hundreds of posts complaining about same issues for years
Then I read stories from longterm users that lose all their data
Hearing stories like this https://forum.inaturalist.org/t/how-to-transfer-seek-observations-to-new-phone/9573/6 it is just absurd the level of disrespect you have to have for your users time and effort. There should be massive warnings that all of your data will be lost and disrespected. It’s tragic but I am thankful others posted about the loss of their years of data so I can avoid the same pitfall by using the app.
I wanted a real world pokedex app.
Why cripple the app with not being able to save your data permanently?
A real world pokedex that stimulates the imagination of children and adults and increases their engagement with the natural world. That lets people save their experiences with the natural world, engage with them later in fun ways and participate in fun community. A place people’s zoo visits, aquarium visits, pets can live on and be the highest upvoted observation on their profile. The classification, badges, achievements are all great. But this privacy ideology is really hamstringing the potential. People lose all of their memories and experiences using your app because you don’t respect their data.
Could have a community showcase like https://www.midjourney.com/showcase/recent/
Could have profile pages with observations & fun stats, specializations, types like
Could have upvotes for observations
A blend of pokedex, pokemon snap, midjourney social features would be an absolutely stellar social and community experience that Seek is on the verge of.
Sounds cool, but it’s not what Seek is designed to be and it’s not the direction we plan to take it in, I’m sorry. As you can see I voted for this feature, so I’m not averse to the idea that Seek observations can be synced or backed-up some way, but Seek really is a privacy-first alternative to iNaturalist, as iNaturalist is all about open data and interacting with a community. Not everyone wants to do that, so we made a fun little alternative that encourages outdoor exploration and learning. If people want the community aspect, they can join iNaturalist.
Much of what you’re asking for is in iNat as far as retaining data and observations go, as well as interacting with others about your experiences in nature and faving observations. I often use it to reminisce about old trips and think about where I’ve been and experiences I’ve had with both nature and friends. But iNat’s also about generating scientifically usable data and having evidence-based discussions - those often don’t go well when incentivized by things like badges and upvotes. Also, and maybe it’s naive, but we hope people enjoy being out in nature because it’s intrinsically cool and fun.
Of course that doesn’t mean the iNat approach is the only way to help people enjoy and engage with nature, so you or someone else could come up with a different app/website with the approach you favor. There’s plenty of room for everyone.
This discussion is getting beyond the original requested feature, so I’m going to ask that we refocus posts to the original request and not broad critiques of Seek or iNat.
1 Like
Ya fair enough adding social features would be a big departure from current design and go against your priority for privacy.
The lack of saving, syncing, backup, export, or import is the more important and relevant issue to OP. I’d use the app if that at least was guaranteed. Can’t commit to using it knowing all my data will be sacrificed.
1 Like