Yellow Warbler Split Question

I am wondering what determines which observations are changed to what species in a taxon split? The recent split of the Yellow Warbler into 2 species– Northern Yellow Warbler and Mangrove Yellow Warbler– sparked my curiosity on this. I have 12 observations that WERE of Yellow Warblers. After the split, ALL of the IDs on 3 of the observations were changed to Northern Yellow Warbler and show evidence of taxon split. But all of the IDs on the other 9 were changed to Mangrove Yellow Warbler and have no mention of the taxon split. (I have attached images of both, each of which were taken at the Sand Dunes in Indiana, so all should be Northern, not Mangrove)

Just curious on what factors go into these. Thanks!

3 Likes

It also may be worth noting that if I suggest the ID as a Northern Yellow Warbler instead of Mangrove, it marks my Northern Yellow ID as maverick. In cases like this where there are 5 incorrectly swapped IDs, what can I do about this?

2 Likes

This taxon change is still processing:

Taxon change commit may still be processing so be aware that some records aren’t yet updated

More about taxon changes, including splits, here: https://www.inaturalist.org/pages/curator+guide#changes

6 Likes

Good to know. Thanks!

1 Like

This thread discusses the taxon change in more detail. Here’s an explanation for the Mangrove Warbler part in particular, which is indirectly because the nominate subspecies (S. petechia petechia) is part of the Golden/Mangrove group rather than the northern group:

2 Likes

Now I will have to say “Northern Yellow Warbler’“ instead of just “Yellow Warbler” just to be specific.