Android app offline guides do not work offline! download pictures, turn internet off, pictures gone!

Platform:androif 15

App version number, if a mobile app issue:1.36.8

Browser, if a website issue:

URLs (aka web addresses) of any relevant observations or pages:

Screenshots of what you are seeing:

Description of problem:

Step 1:Android app offline guides do not work offline! download the offline guide with pictures, turn internet off, return to guide, pictures gone!

Step 2:

Step 3:

guides are a very old part of the system. they are at least deprecated, if not altogether unsupported at this point.

that said, here’s some relevant discussion related to your issue from back in the day: https://forum.inaturalist.org/t/downloading-guides-offline-mobile-downloads-represent-a-considerable-burden-on-our-system/19647/2.

So, if you want to take advantage of the work that inaturalists have done …by making guides available offline, here is a dumb solution. The fact that coders can’t fix this problem - “display a picture and a piece of text from a database that is already organized that way and downloadable to your phone if the phone does not have a running internet connection” is an indictment of, at best, lack of care.

Find the guide using inaturalist.org

Print it as a pdf (which uses up 10x the memory that the images use in the database of the guide, because pdfs don’t natively compress images!)

Transfer it to your phone

Not as good as the original. But better than nothing.

But why if the download version does not work, then have the option on the Android phone to download it?

Or at least warn users that it wont work if you do try to download it?