Catalan common names

Platform: iNaturalist

Browser, if a website issue: Chrome (in Ecosia)

URLs (aka web addresses) of any relevant observations or pages: https://www.inaturalist.org/taxa/148030-Equus-asinus

Screenshots of what you are seeing:

image

Description of problem:

I have my display set to Catalan names first, English names second. Very often, the common name displayed for Catalan is nothing like what I know from my area - fine - there are a few common names around. But I have never heard “ase” for donkey. When I went to see how easy it is to add a new name, the system told me “ruc” already exists. So why isn’t it being displayed for me? This is the correct common name for everyone I know. This isn’t the first time I have noticed a weird common name - I’ve shown it to other people who’ve also never heard of the word used. But my main question is, why am I not given Ruc when it exists in the database?

Thank you!

But my main question is, why am I not given Ruc/Ase/Burro when it exists in the database?

If there is more then one name (3) iNaturalist has to choose one.
I should call it priority:
58 Ruc
59 Ase
60 Burro

Refresh and try again. I am not sure if the change of priority is correct. Both sources mention Ase first…
I contacted the creater of ‘‘Ase’’ ( and all three Catalan donkey names).

Maybe you should not mark it as a bug but as a flag with the taxon?

I changed it but AI says:

  • Ase and ruc are both correct Catalan words for donkey.
  • Ase is the standard, traditional word for a donkey in Catalan, while ruc is also widely used, especially in everyday or regional speech.
  • For the specific local breed, both Ase Català and Ruc Català are officially recognized names. [1, 2, 3, 4]

And wiki:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catalan_donkey

Cool, thank you! It still shows up as Ase, but I understand better. Occasionally I use a Catalan term for something that I’ve picked up from iNat when I’m talking to a friend and they have no idea what I’m talking about. “Ase” is one of these - I just tested it out and it took several moments before the friend got what I was talking about!

So you are not a native speaker of Catalan?

No, I speak it daily but I’m a learner.

I tried it for Catalan / Catala but I do not see a difference too. As far as I can see no locations are added to theses names, so in my opinion it should show Ruc now..

I had my display set to locale first, English names second. That configuration still showed the old names. Removing the second English common name solved the problem. At least I know the configuration now is right…
So in the end it seems not a flag but a bug or a caching problem.
Reconfigure it to display 2 common names gives the correct name..

Oh yeah, that works! I guess I just have to move 100% into Catalan then :joy:

In the end the other configuration will work too.

In the forum you can find more info about common names:
https://forum.inaturalist.org/t/common-name-in-french-instead-of-english/75983