How does one list all ungrafted taxa?

I try to for the ones I’m comfortable resolving. There are more than a few in there that cannot be resolved because they are in locked groups.

You can also browse through some ungrafted taxa that have observations here: https://www.inaturalist.org/observations?hrank=kingdom&iconic_taxa=unknown&place_id=any&verifiable=any&view=species&without_taxon_id=131236,67333,151817

2 Likes

Thanks @bouteloua, this is exactly what I was looking for!

M.

1 Like

Wow. Quite a few of those ungrafted taxa are long extinct species that have no place on iNaturalist.

I don’t think that’s really a fair conclusion, extinct species just often don’t fit neatly into the artificial tree

My response probably came off more harsh than intended, but from a curator point of view, the inability to neatly incorporate them into the tree can be a little frustrating at times and sometimes detracts from work needed for extant species - the ones that would most benefit from iNaturalist. Since observations of long extinct taxa are almost always vertebrates (e.g. dinosaurs, mammoths) and that is the section of the tree I primarily deal with, it’s possible that inflated the issue from my perspective.

1 Like

I had a go at quite a few of the plant species.

Interestingly there were a couple left that had been the subject of a taxon swap, and somehow got left behind:

In both cases it looks like the taxon swap missed one of the IDs. Not sure how to handle these ones.

This is one of the main practical problems with accepting the split of Nothofagus into four genera: the majority of fossil Nothofagus will be left with no genus, as we just don’t know what genus they would have belonged to, or even if the new genera would have applied to them.

Given that user opts out of community ID, it’s possible they’re also opting out of taxon swaps in their account settings.

Ahhh… I didn’t notice they’d opted out. Thanks @bouteloua

I made a few modifications to @pisum’s code for displaying iNat API responses. Presenting a new way to view ungrafted taxa:

5 Likes

Quick update: it’s now sortable and filterable and with more links and things.
It also no longer takes URL parameters, it’s just https://jumear.github.io/stirfry/iNat_Ungrafted_taxa.html

Feedback welcome!

2 Likes

Very useful, thanks @jwidness!

1 Like

We broke 400, good job everyone!

2 Likes

I don’t know exactly who to give credit to – probably @mftasp, @cmcheatle, and others – but we’re really blasting through these lately!

image

1 Like

There seem to be a bunch of ungrafted higher-order plant taxa (Fabales—multiple copies, Ginkgooidae, Cyperales, Alismatidae…) that cannot be inactivated by normal curators.

Most of these have flags that have seen no action. Who are the higher-level plant curators, and is it OK to personally tag them in some of these flags?

There are no plant curators.

Higher order taxa changes can only be done by staff regardless of it is an open or locked area .

1 Like

yeah, that’s got a bug report

They all fit! Plus @tiwane said he’d see what he can do about the fact that close to half the list is now editable only by staff.

1 Like

The list keeps shrinking, well done anyone who’s helped!

2 Likes