Platform: Web App version number: Browser: Firefox URLs of any relevant observations or pages: https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/173833633 https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/220764467 Screenshots of what you are seeing: [Screen Shot 2024-10-14 at 10.01.03 PM] Description of prob…

If there are multiple people adding different IDs, sometimes if you disagree with say the original identifier, but the community ID is now pretty broad and your ID is a subcategory of that community ID, you don’t get asked if you disagree.

These were cases where no one had yet disagreed with the original species level ID, I added a broader ID in the identify window, and it did not ask me if I disagreed, and then I deleted that ID and started over in a non-identify window on the same observation, and made the same ID, and then it did a…

Now that you mention it, I think I’ve occasionally had that happen to me too, and as you said, deleting the ID and trying again then gets you the option to disagree. It seems to happen kind of randomly. Mysterious.

In my case deleting and trying again does not work, I have to open the observation in it’s own window, not the identify window, and then it works

Or overlapping with someone else adding an ID? I trip over asking someone to withdraw their broad ID to Plantae - then I have to make sure that their intended disagreement ‘not that sp’ is still recognised by iNat. By adding an appropriate disagreeing taxon ID - or iNat graciously reverts to Needs …

I honestly can’t tell what this comment refers to at all. I will say in these cases I encountered no one else was adding IDs when I was

I’m not sure if I understand your problem correctly as your screenshot isn’t of the identify page… From what I’ve understood and seen, the disagreement will only show if you pick something at a similar taxon level (for example the observer has a species picked and you pick a different one). If you …

[image] Jewlsinnature: I’m not sure if I understand your problem correctly as your screenshot isn’t of the identify page… I did not screenshot the identify page because I’m not sure how to screenshot the lack of a popup I am doing the exact same ID in the identify window and the other windo…

[image] Jewlsinnature: If you pick something (from the Identify page using the suggestion tab) at a higher taxon level that encompasses the choice of the observer it won’t disagree automatically or have the window pop-up. If you want to do this in the Identify page you have to make sure you inpu…

I see, I am always using the info tab, so the fact that I don’t get a popup does seem like a bug

Menue asking if you disagree fails to show up in identify window

Bug Reports

insectobserver123 October 22, 2024, 11:49pm 20

This is odd, because I do not use the suggestions tab

Topic		Replies	Views
Identify page / State of matter Life / Disagreeing should be allowed Bug Reports	14	1118	January 29, 2021
Potential disagreement popup does not show up when selecting a higher taxa from suggestions tab in identify mode Bug Reports web , staff-can-replicate , issue-made	4	141	February 14, 2025
Offer the ability to choose whether to hard disagree or not to the next finest level that the current identifications support, when one disagrees with the current community id Feature Requests	7	1260	November 5, 2019
Disagreements with myself are not labelled as disagreements Bug Reports web	13	551	January 16, 2021
Can't disagree with one specific observation Bug Reports staff-can-replicate , issue-made	15	1088	June 19, 2023

Menue asking if you disagree fails to show up in identify window

Related topics