Themes in Poetry Anthology about Extinction

Hi iNat community,

New member here.

I’m a poet and author in the brainstorming stage of putting together a poetry / prose anthology on extinction. Unfortunately, my only qualification for this project is my love of nature and existential anxiety of seeing the world burn, and I have no idea where to start.

So I wanted to come to you all to ask and pick your brain:

If you came across an anthology about extinction, what sort of topics and themes would you expect to be included?

Any species of animals you’d wish to read about? Perhaps one that doesn’t get talked about enough? What would get you to pick up the book?

Any thoughts and ideas would be a huge help, and you’ll definitely get a shoutout once the project is completed!

Many thanks

4 Likes

I’ve been studying mollusks for years now and only just came across this statistic. I think these extinctions are mostly land snails (particularly Pacific islands after rosy wolf snail introductions) and freshwater mussels (particularly in the Southeastern US from habitat degradation). Both these groups are pretty well known among malacologists and have robust conservation programs (at least for invertebrates) but I don’t know how much the average person knows about them.

On another note, I would also like to see success stories of recoveries from near extinction. It can be easy to get lost in the doom and gloom, but I think there is also a lot to be hopeful for (dire wolf does not count…).

3 Likes

Cool project!
I think a section with once-thought-extinct-but-rediscovered animals could be nice, some hope among the sorrow.
Another one I’d read is how alpine communities are suffering because of climate change, and how they go up until they find the peak and can’t go any higher.

2 Likes

This sounds really cool! I will readily read anything related to extinct Hawai’ian bird species and really anything about extinct species in Hawai’i in general. I don’t know how many poems you intend on making, but I think a poem on each of the Hawai’ian islands could be cool (including islands like Laysan a.k.a. Kauō), since they’ve all suffered from a large loss of biodiversity, in both plants and animals.

I also agree with what thomaseverest and oksanaetal have said and think it would be cool to highlight some of the conservation successes in the world as a reminder that there is still hope.

1 Like

Also some thoughts on ancient extinction events.

3 Likes

I don’t know the source of this statistic, so please correct me if I’m wrong, but I suspect this impressive statistic comes about because of inherent bias in the data used. I would guess that what is actually meant is that 40% of documented extinctions in the last 400 years are non-marine mollusks. And this (again I’m guessing) is largely due to the fact that non-marine mollusks leave behind copious shells that can be IDed to species even if the species was extinct before it was described scientifically. And those shells have so many amazing details that it is easy to find traits upon which species delineations can be hung. So I’d guess that the great majority of extinctions in the last 500 years have been organisms humans will never know existed. If we were able to split nematodes into species as easily as mollusks, and they left behind as many clearly identifiable remains, we might be saying that the vast majority of animals going extinct in the last 500 years were nematodes. The same might be said of mites.

1 Like

Here is the citation:
https://academic.oup.com/bioscience/article/54/4/321-330/284125

Yes, this is for recorded extinctions.

4 Likes

For me, the topics and themes I’d expect to see included are different than the ones I’d wish to see included. There are certain facts, examples, and views about extinction that tend to be covered whenever the topic comes up, and I’d expect to see those. I’d wish to see something that diverges from that path.

Which leads to this part of your question:

There are far too many that don’t get talked about much! A few examples:

The extinction of parasites and commensals that lived on other species (imagine the variety of things that lived on and in dinosaurs).

The parallels between biological extinctions and linguistic and cultural extinctions.

The Silurian Hypothesis (as described in this Eons video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vyEWLhOfLgQ )

How little we know about the chemical ecology, behavior, vocalizations, senses, etc. of long-extinct species and our tendency to assume they didn’t have interesting traits in these areas despite the ubiquity of interesting traits in modern species.

The timescales on which biodiversity recovers after major extinction events.

The fact that many children are more familiar with certain long extinct species than those alive now.

The ongoing effort to drive Guinea Worm to extinction.

The misunderstanding, hype, and fraud around resurrecting extinct species.

3 Likes

Just to clarify: by “putting together an anthology” do you mean collecting work by other writers on the topic, or a collection of your own (yet-to-be-written) texts? I ask because I understand “anthology” in the former sense and I would refer to the latter as a “collection”. but sometimes I see people using anthology for both. It makes a difference how to respond to your post depending on whether the challenge is to find existing texts or topics for writing your own.

The inner heartbreak when scientists see the organisms they love disappear, while the public doesn’t care or is ignorant, the inner rage at selfish corporations and politicians; but not being able to speak up because they have to practice censorship in order to be able to work at all.

4 Likes

This would be an anthology in the former sense. Other writers will (hopefully) share their work for this project. I learned early on that the project deserves the expertise and passion of many voices and viewpoints, not just my own.

Thank you! The title’ A Scientist’s Lament’ comes to mind. Definitely worth exploring the frustration and heartbreak from those doing so much but falling on deaf ears.

1 Like

Thank you!

A running idea I have is to couple or pair together an extinct species in a poetic form that comes from the country of origin, i.e. an Australian bush poem about the Tasmanian tiger

Also, definitely will consider the final ‘arc’ of the anthology to focus on hopeful themes, animals back from the brink of extinction, species thought to be extinct, etc.

2 Likes

I am working on a poem about American Bison!

Or, what the heck, elk are more “from where I live” for me since the USA is a big country.
I’m not much of a poet, but perhaps I’ll learn.

Passenger Pigeons

Slowly the passenger pigeons increased, then suddenly their
Numbers became enormous,

They would flatten ten miles of forest when they flew down to roost,

And the cloud of their rising eclipsed the dawns.

They became too many, they are all dead not one remains.

And the American bison: their hordes would hide a prairie from
Horizon to horizon, great heads and storm-cloud shoulders,

A torrent of life - how many are left ?

For a time, for a few years, their hones turned the dark prairies white.

You, Death, you watch for these things. These explosions of life.-
They are your food. They make your feasts.

But turn your great rolling eyes away from humanity

Those grossly craving black eyes. It is true we increase.

A man from Britain landing in Gaul when Rome had fallen he journeyed
Fourteen days inland through that beautiful rich land,

The orchards and rivers and the looted villas-.

He reports he saw no living man.

But now we fill the gaps. In spite of wars, famines and pestilences
We are c/uite suddenly three billion people:

Our hones, ours too, would make wide prairies white,

A beautiful snow of unhuried hones-.

Bones that have twitched and cjuivered in the nights of love,

Bones that have shaken with laughter and hung slack in sorrow,

Coward bones worn out with trembling,

Strong bones broken on the rack, bones broken in battle,

Broad bones gnarled with hard labor, and the little bones
Of sweet young children,

And the white empty skulls, Little carved ivory wine-jugs that used
To contain passion and thought and love and insane delirium,
Where now not even worms live

Respect humanity, Death, these shameless black eyes of yours,

It is not necessary to take all at once - besides that,

You cannot do it, we are too powerful, we are men, not pigeons,

You may take the old, the useless and helpless, the cancer-bitten

And the tender young, but the human race has still history to make.
For look - look now at our achievements.-

We have bridled the cloud-leaper lightning,

A lion whipped by a man, to carry our messages and work our will,

We have snatched the thunderbolt out of God’s hands.

Ha? That was little and last year - for now we have taken the
Primal powers, creation and annihilation;

We make new elements, such as God never saw,

We can explode atoms and annul the fragments, nothing left
But pure energy, we shall use it in peace and war -
“Very clever ,” he answered in his thin piping voice, cruel and a eunuch.

Roll those idiot black eyes of yours on the field-beats,

Not on intelligent man, We are not in your order.

You watched the dinosaurs grow into horror.-
They had been little elves in the ditches and presently became enormous
With leaping flanks and tearing teeth, plated with armor, nothing
could stand against them, nothing but you, death, and they died.

You watched the saber-tooth timers develop those huge fangs,

Unnecessary as our sciences, and presently they died.

You have their hones in the oil-pits and layer rock, you will not have ours.
With pain and wonder and labor we have bought intelligence.

We have minds like the tusks of those forgotten timers,

Hypertrophied and terrible,

We have counted the stars and half-understood them,

We have watched the farther galaxies fleeing away from us,

Wild herds of panic horses - or a trick of distance deceived by the prism -
We outfly falcons and eagles and meteors, faster than sound,

Higher than the nourishing air,

We have enormous privilege, we do not fear you, we have invented
The jet-plane and the death-bomb and the cross of Christ -
“Oh ,” he said, “surely you’ll live forever” -
Grinning like a skull, covering his mouth with his hand -
“What could exterminate you?”

From Robinson Jeffers, “The Beginning and the End”

A lot of interesting work was done on “Jeffers and the Anthropocene” about a decade ago. Last lines of the poem seem to describe current situation of “anthropocene denial,” as does the spell checker. Humans deluding themselves that they are still living in the “holocene” (whatever that means)…

1 Like

When I first read your topic, my mind went immediately to Richard Wilbur’s poem “Advice to a Prophet” (old but very effective still), especially the last stanza:

Ask us, ask us whether with the worldless rose
Our hearts shall fail us; come demanding
Whether there shall be lofty or long standing
When the bronze annals of the oak-tree close.

So, I guess my answer is more general–I would read an anthology about extinctions of all types if the poetry were well written. And, I think such an anthology would be in much demand for teaching.