Please fill out the following sections to the best of your ability, it will help us investigate bugs if we have this information at the outset. Screenshots are especially helpful, so please provide those if you can. Platform (Android, iOS, Website): Website URLs (aka web addresses) of any relevant…

You only get the flair if the ID disagrees with the observation taxon at the time of the ID. As far as I can tell, the observation taxon at the time was subfamily (same as now), so the tribe ID didn’t disagree with it.

3 IDs across 2 tribes puts it in sub-family. Not yet enough consensus for - this is disagreement. Hard to move that ID. Only 2 obs on iNat, but maybe the observer will reconsider? (That is why the 2 against 1 Pre-Mavericks are both challenging and rewarding)

Yes, I agree that the calculation is correct because there is in fact a disagreement (possibly an accidental one in this case but that is irrelevant). What I think is a bug is the fact that there is no indication that there is a disagreement; normally if some observer IDs something as ‘genus allium’…

So, the sequence is probably something like 1.) ID to species X 2.) Disagreeing ID to species Y 3.) Higher level ID that agrees with species X but not Y 4.) second ID to species Y 5.) species X ID withdrawn I guess there is a design choice in not adding the disagreement flair retroactively so …

No Indication of Disagreement

Bug Reports

DianaStuder June 19, 2023, 9:39pm 6

If you want to see this - join the Pre-Maverick project where you will get a link.
https://www.inaturalist.org/projects/pre-maverick/members?page=4

Topic		Replies	Views
Obs has 0.8 support for species ID but community and observation IDs stuck at genus level Bug Reports	14	578	June 8, 2021
ID is red in Community Taxon section but is not a disagreement Bug Reports web	15	1203	January 31, 2026
Can't disagree with one specific observation Bug Reports staff-can-replicate , issue-made	15	1085	June 19, 2023
Disagreeing identification retroactively interpreted as "parent taxon but not child taxon" disagreement Bug Reports	18	907	December 10, 2022
Issue with disagree on ID not working correctly Bug Reports	3	493	May 23, 2019

No Indication of Disagreement

Related topics