System text in observation when user disallows adding to projects

When a user does not allow their observations to be added to projects, it would be nice to see that noted upfront.

Similar to when a user has opted out of community ID and there is a iNaturalist generated line of text to inform others.

Also similar to this recent feature, where if users don’t allow observation fields to be filled out there is a line of text informing identifyers: https://forum.inaturalist.org/t/disable-option-to-add-an-observation-field-if-observer-has-opted-out/7109

especially the Opted out of CID. Such an irritating waste of effort when a string of people ID that … and it remains determined at Needs ID … for ever.

2 Likes

@dianastuder, do you mean the opt-out should show in the identification modal?

Because it’s already shown in the observation in the community ID section under the map:

1 Like

I have learned to scroll past if there are already 2 IDs that agree, especially if at least one is someone I trust. And I have learned to check first, why a string of people are trying to convince Needs ID.

We could save our wasted effort if Needs ID was greyed out as Opted Out. Or go ahead with ID knowing that iNat will NEVER be convinced.

2 Likes

I would not say it will never be convinced, I have certainly seen cases where opt out users change their ID when they realize after multiple community ones they are wrong. But, yes the automatically determined ID will never change.

2 Likes

Ah, ok. :) Well, that’s a separate issue. My “ask” is just for adding text to the observation itself re: user has opted out of having others add their observations to projects (either ones they haven’t subscribed to or at all).

personal settings for projects

iNat staff, I’d just like a text blurb warning, like IDs already had for opt-outs and observation fields just got for opt-outs.

image

image

2 Likes

Sorry - shall I delete my comments?

No, it’s fine. :)
It helped me clarify what I was asking for, and prompted some good discussion.

If you really want them greyed out, though, I think you should open a feature request for that.

1 Like

Seems to have been implemented:

I don’t see any texts about projects in that screenshot?

Oh, I misread the original request. Well, I guess it’s halfway there… :/

1 Like

Yeah, the observation field system text was an example for my request (and later a side discussion).

What I am requesting is something like this:

image

Sorry, I can’t edit my previous comments to include this mockup, so I had to add it in a new comment.

1 Like

Apparently I made a github issue for this back in the olden days of January: https://github.com/inaturalist/inaturalist/issues/2571

1 Like

Oh, wonderful!

Otherwise, you don’t know this option is unavailable until AFTER you go through the process of adding an observation to a project.
image

1 Like

I’ll leave this open, though, since that’s what I was told the last time there was a github that matched my feature request.

1 Like