Drag and Drop upload doesn't work

Platform: Web

App version number, if a mobile app issue: n/a

Browser, if a website issue: Chrome

URLs (aka web addresses) of any relevant observations or pages: https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/upload

Screenshots of what you are seeing:



Description of problem: I’ve noticed this basically the whole time I’ve been on iNat, but since I never drag and drop anything, I’ve forgotten and never reported it

Step 1: Go to upload

Step 2: Drag and drop; see “drop it”

Step 3: Nothing happens

What is the source of your photos (what program, app, etc.) and what format of photos (jpg? png?) are you trying to upload.

On my MacBook Pro (Tahoe 26.6.2) using Chrome, I have no trouble dragging and dropping jpegs either from Photos or from a Finder window.

I use Drag and Drop on a PC and Chrome and jpgs. No problems!

I was dragging a jpg from eBird. I just tried photos from a few other sites, including iNat, and had the same issue. I was able to get it to work it I drag and drop from File Explorer.

Save the image onto your pc before uploading. Do this by right clicking on the image and click “save image as” when the little menu pops up. Then you can browse for a place on your PC to save it to. Then you can drag and drop.

You had eBird’s website open in another browser tab or window and dragged a photo directly from it into the iNat web uploader? Just making sure I’m understanding your process.

Yes, dragged directly from ebird and some other places. The only thing that worked was file explorer

I’m pretty sure the uploader was never designed for this use case, the assumption is that the photos are on your computer and will be uploaded from there, not from another website. Whether or not that should be how it works is debatable, but I don’t think this is a bug.

Gotcha, I tried eBird, BugGuide, GBIF, etc. The only thing that works is files from computer… When a photo from another website is dragged it says “drop it” which makes it seem like it would work. :)

I just confirmed the same behavior. Dragging and dropping directly from an image on a different web page fails to “stick” on the iNat upload page, whereas the same exact image saved as a jpeg to my Mac desktop (via drag-and-drop) is thereafter accepted on the iNat upload page. However, I note that dragging and dropping to the desktop as an intermediate step (even of my own original images on some website) creates a brand new file which seems to only have a numerical filename (dimension?) and the jpg extension–all original metadata is lost.
Conclusion: Only attempt to upload from original photo files on the Mac/PC.

I think the current functionality is good and wouldn’t want users to be able to drag and drop photos directly from other webpages to the iNat uploader. This would make uploading faked/copyright infringing observations much quicker and easier and could lead to an even higher incidence of fraudulent observations during CNC, poor class projects, etc.

Gotcha, I never use it anyway :) Thank you!

Perhaps a short message window

  • “Please only upload pictures directly from your computer” or
  • “Uploads via drag and drop from external pages are not allowed”

could be helpfull as alternative to just a grey site irritating the user?