Is it possible to identify "The Very Hungry Caterpillar" by Eric Carle?

Maybe I have been studying too much for my Final Exams, but this idea first popped into my mind while eating Cheetos Puffs. How would I classify the Puffs from the regular Cheetos? As different genera, different species, e.t.c?

While staring at the Puffs, they first reminded me of bacilli bacteria or filoviridae (yes, I am a science nerd). Then, after I ate the last of the Puffs, I started to contemplate watching SPECIES: ALRE again (a videogame about evolution using artificial life). Watching difference artificial lifeforms diverge into different species is fascinating, and I was even inspired to make-up a Linnaean-type classification scheme.

All of this segued to “The Very Hungry Caterpillar”, a book I remember reading as a child. Even though it features a made-up caterpillar with a make-believe diet, this caterpillar goes through the entire Lepidoptera lifecycle. With all of the aforementioned information still circling in my mind, I wondered: is it possible to identify “The Very Hungry Caterpillar”?

Here is the link for those who like to watch the video version of this childhood gem:


Superfamily Papilionoidea. Experts can narrow down further. :-)


A summary for those interested.

Morphological characteristics:

Egg – indistinct, round and white.

Larva – similar characteristics throughout instars. Body: distinctly segmented, finely pubescent, predominantly green with yellow on the dorsal surface. Legs and prolegs: brown (lacking full complement of prolegs). Head: red with purple antenna and green/yellow eyes. Has a tongue… breaths through mouth… Do the missing prolegs confirm that this is in the family Geometridae i.e. inchworms?

Pupa – Brown.

Adult – Forewing unusually lobed. Upper and lower wing surfaces similar. Forewing: blue, green and yellow with a large red eye-spot and several smaller red and orange spots. Hindwing: purple, green, orange, with an orange/yellow eye-spot. Head: red with green/yellow eyes. Thorax and abdomen: yellow. Adult does not look like a Geometrid?

Behavioural characteristics:

Egg – laid on upper surface of leaf

Larva – Inches along with the appendages at opposite ends of the body. Larval period of 1 week before pupating.

Pupa - hung from lower surface of leaf. More than 2 weeks before emerging as a butterfly (perhaps 3 weeks as he hatched from his egg near full moon and pupated 1 week later and then emerged from the pupa near full moon again)

Larval diet:


Predominantly fruit (apple, pear, plums, strawberries & oranges)

Also chocolate cake, Ice cream cone, pickle, Swiss cheese, salami, lollipop, cherry pie, sausage, cupcake, watermelon. These items made him sick so presumably atypical.

A leaf of the host plant (laid on, eaten and pupated on) confirmed as a plum tree by the narrator. Leaves: Entire, cordate, glabrous.

General habitat: cultivated countryside

Other plants in vicinity: grass, ferns, dandelion or similar yellow Asteraceae, night flowering Ipomea or similar. Rubus species. Small purple flowering plant, curiously both 4 and 5 petaled. Yellow sunflowers or similar.

The bird calls are not familiar, perhaps European species?


Once we ID that one, maybe we could have a go at the ones in “Hope for the Flowers,” by Trina Paulus

1 Like

I have just noticed a continuity error where the larva has 2 pairs of true legs and the adult has its full compliment of 3 pairs of legs. hmmm


My first thought is that no Lepidopteran caterpillar has such prominent eyes, so it must be a sawfly larva! But if they are eyespots rather than true eyes, maybe this caterpillar is a swallowtail. That would explain the “antennae” (actually a smelly osmeterium) as well. Unfortunately, the adult butterfly doesn’t look anything like a swallowail, so I’m stumped! :)


Very intriguing. The caterpillar antennae is reminiscent of the osmeterium found in Papilionidae, though the body segments remind me of a Saturniidae caterpillar, similar to an Antheraea polyphemus. The pupa, with the cremaster hanging down in that manner is akin to the Nymphalidae, though the pupa itself is more moth-like. The beautiful wings are reminiscent of the dazzling sunset moths in Uraniidae, while the downturned antennae refer to Nymphalidae too, specifically Danainae and some Satyrinae too (Papilionidae antennae hook upwards).


I did the same thing as this with a friend but with ‘Shrek’. It was quite fun, we classed it as an Amphibian but I cant remember the rest of the taxonomy that we made up (I jotted it down in a notebook somewhere).


In my turn I have consumed cheese puffs while studying. I’ve wondered about the “The Very Hungry Caterpillar” myself. How fun! You might enjoy watching my latest video “Christmas With . . . Moths.” Have a good week!


i uploaded this pic to look at the ai suggestions:


it is telling me that it could be the common geranium-bronze butterfly… or a venus flytrap. lol! the caterpillar is suitably poofy and green imo


Very interesting!

Reading the Lorax with my kids tonight, I thought I’d scan him in. He was identified as “Human” - with a Common Lionfish as a second choice. :)


That’s hilarious.:joy:

Next, try the brown bar-ba-loots, swomi swans, and humming-fish – and the truffula trees for good measure.


What about this one? His head isn’t red and he isn’t hairy but he does have big eyes!image


This topic was automatically closed 60 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.